Patagonia Stormshadow Parka vs Fjällräven Expedition Long Down Parka

The Patagonia Stormshadow is the better pick for wet, mixed winter weather: its GORE-TEX ePE shell is genuinely waterproof and breathable, and 700-fill recycled down keeps it warm at a fraction of the bulk. The Fjällräven Expedition Long is the colder-weather specialist, with far more down fill, a longer loose cut and a down-synthetic blend that shrugs off damp cold. Reviewers praise Patagonia's build and warranty; Fjällräven owners rate the Expedition's warmth but note its weight and bulk.

• Choose the Patagonia Stormshadow Parka if you face rain and slush as often as cold and want one hooded parka that works in the city and on the hill.
• Choose the Fjällräven Expedition Long Down Parka if you live in deep, dry cold and want maximum loft, length and coverage over layers.