Pen+Gear #2 HB Unsharpened Wood Pencils vs Ticonderoga Wooden Pencil #2

Buy the Ticonderoga if you want the pencil most schools and test-takers trust: its 2.2mm #2 soft lead is smoother and resists breaking better than most store brands, and the cedar body sharpens cleanly. Buy the Pen+Gear 24-pack if you just need a dependable yellow #2 for desks, classrooms and shared supply bins and don't need premium lead. Owners rate the Pen+Gear highly at 4.7 from over 11,000 ratings, but Ticonderoga's long-standing reputation for consistent lead and fewer duds gives it the edge on build and writing feel.

• Choose the Pen+Gear 24-pack if you want a simple, familiar yellow #2 pencil in a smaller count for everyday notes, homework and shared desks.
• Choose the Ticonderoga 72-pack if you want smoother, break-resistant #2 lead and a larger supply that lasts a classroom or a full school year.