Which is better for wearing in rain or heat?

The New Era 59FIFTY. Its nylon shell is water-resistant and it has a quick-dry sweatband and vented eyelets. The '47 Clean Up is cotton twill and will soak up water.

Which fits more head sizes?

The '47 Clean Up. It is one size with an adjustable self-fabric strap. The New Era is fitted, so you must order your exact size.

Is the New Era worth about $19 more?

If you want a fitted, water-resistant cap for game days, yes. If you want a soft everyday hat at the lowest price, the '47 at $26.25 is the better value.

Which looks more like the on-field sideline hat?

The New Era. It is the 2026 Sideline design with a silicone Eagles patch and rear NFL Shield. The '47 is a casual raised-embroidery logo hat.

Which holds its shape longer?

The New Era's structured fitted build holds its shape better over time. The '47's garment-washed cotton is soft and unstructured by design.

Which is better for everyday casual wear?

The '47 Clean Up. The washed cotton and relaxed adjustable fit suit daily wear, and it costs less.

New Era Eagles 2026 Sideline 59FIFTY vs '47 Eagles Clean Up Hat

Buy the '47 Clean Up if you want a relaxed, adjustable everyday hat for about $26.25 at DICK'S Sporting Goods as of November 6, 2026. Buy the New Era 59FIFTY if you want a fitted, water-resistant sideline cap for $44.99 at Amazon as of November 6, 2026. The New Era costs about $19 more and comes only in fitted sizes, so know your head size first.

Today the '47 Eagles Clean Up Hat costs $18.74 less at its best price.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.