Which is brighter, the Philips or the GE?

The Philips at 4200 lumens is clearly brighter, about 68% more output than the GE's 2500 lumens. Choose the Philips for large driveways or dark backyards.

Do I need an electrician for either one?

The Philips is hardwired, so plan on wiring, often by an electrician. The GE is solar and cordless, so you can mount it yourself with no wiring.

Does the GE work in shade?

Yes, within limits. Its 10 ft cord lets you move the solar panel away from shade, and buyers report it holds a charge in dappled shade. Charging can still be inconsistent in low light.

Is the Philips worth the extra $70?

If you need maximum brightness and power that does not depend on the sun, yes. If a simple self-install matters more, the GE at $89 at Walmart as of November 3 is the better value.

Which has better motion coverage?

The GE covers 240° up to 40 ft. The Philips covers 180°. The GE wins on detection range and angle.

The Philips has no battery to age, so its hardwired LED should hold output longer. The GE's solar battery will degrade over years of charging cycles.

Philips 44W 4200 lm LED Security Light Outdoor w/PIR Motion Sensor, 5000K Daylight Flood Light, Waterproof, Dusk to Dawn, 2 Heads, 4 Modes vs GE Outdoor Security Floodlights

Buy the Philips if you need maximum brightness and a hardwired fixture that never depends on the sun. Buy the GE if you want a no-wiring solar install and can live with less light. The Philips is listed at $159 at Distritech as of November 3; the GE is $89 at Walmart as of November 3, so the GE costs about $70 less.

Ask our shopping agent