Which is better for oily skin?

The Milani. It is oil-free and water-resistant with a semi-matte finish that controls shine. The Picture Perfect is radiant and luminizing, which can look shinier on oily skin.

Which gives more coverage?

The Milani. It builds to full coverage and doubles as a concealer for redness and under-eye circles. The Picture Perfect tops out at buildable medium.

Is the Milani worth the extra $4?

For most shoppers, yes. You get fuller coverage, a two-in-one formula, and a 4.1 rating from 2,366 buyers versus 3.8 from 86. The Picture Perfect only wins if price is the deciding factor.

Which is better for a dewy, natural look?

The Picture Perfect. Its radiant, luminizing finish gives a glow that the semi-matte Milani does not. Choose it for everyday sheer coverage.

Which has more shades?

The Picture Perfect lists 24 shades. The Milani is sold in multiple shades, but check the specific shade stock before buying.

Which lasts longer through a day?

The Milani. Its water-resistant, sweatproof, oil-free formula is built for longwear. The Picture Perfect claims long lasting but has no water-resistance claim.

Picture Perfect Luminizing Liquid Foundation vs Milani Conceal + Perfect 2-in-1 Foundation Concealer

Buy the Milani Conceal + Perfect if you want fuller coverage, oil control, and a two-in-one base; it costs $9.09 at Ulta Beauty and rates 4.1 from 2,366 ratings. Buy the Picture Perfect Luminizing Liquid Foundation only if you want the lowest price and a dewy, radiant look; it is $4.99 and rates 3.8 from 86 ratings. The Milani costs about $4 more but has far more ratings and a semi-matte, water-resistant formula. The Picture Perfect is the cheaper entry point but has a much thinner track record.

Ask our shopping agent