StoreDeal.ai store
Shop
  • Deals
  • Deal checker
  • Black Friday
  • Buying guides
  • Brands
  • Stores
Travel
  • Flight deals
  • Hotel deals
Company
  • Research
  • Press
  • Use in AI assistants
  • Contact
  • deal.ai apps
Black Friday 2026
  • Walmart
  • Best Buy
  • Target
  • TVs
  • Laptops
  • Headphones
  • Apple
  • Gaming
  • Vacuums
  • Kitchen
  • Toys
  • Smartwatches
  • Tablets
  • Furniture
  • Mattresses
© Deal.ai Inc.·2222 Ponce de Leon Blvd, Miami, FL 33134·support@deal.ai
TermsPrivacy
Deal.ai › Compare

Pine Cologne Oil vs Pine Solid Cologne

Pick the roll-on oil if you want a scent that stays with you all day and a bottle you can refill. Pick the solid balm if you want a soft, skin-friendly pine that never spills and doubles as a moisturizer. The oil is stronger and more resinous, with a pineapple twist; the balm is a cleaner, quieter forest scent in a wax-and-coconut base. Owners of the oil praise how long it lasts; owners of the balm praise how gentle it is on skin.

  • Choose the PINE Cologne Oil if you want a strong, long-lasting unisex pine scent in a refillable glass roll-on you can carry in a pocket or glove box.
  • Choose the Pine Solid Cologne if you want an alcohol-free pine balm that moisturizes, won't leak, and stays subtle through the day.

Prices

  • Pine Cologne Oil: $13.00 at Humphrey's Handmade (last seen Nov 20)
  • Pine Solid Cologne: $7.50 at Scalise Family Sheep Farm (last seen Nov 20)
  • Difference: the Pine Solid Cologne is $5.50 cheaper than the Pine Cologne Oil at the latest prices (Nov 20)
P
PINE Cologne Oil

Pine Cologne Oil

PINE Cologne Oil

5(1 rating)
$13.00at Humphrey's HandmadeChecked 4 h ago
See all prices and details
Visit Humphrey's Handmade
Pros
  • Very long lasting, strong projection
  • Refillable BPA-free glass roll-on
  • Vegan and paraben-free
  • Unisex pine-woods scent with a pineapple edge
  • Pocket and glove-box size
Cons
  • Oil can leak if the cap comes loose
  • Strong scent may be too much for close offices
  • Glass bottle is less rugged than a tin
  • Fragrance oil, not an all-natural balm
P
Pine Solid Cologne – Natural Pine Fragrance Balm

Pine Solid Cologne

Pine Solid Cologne – Natural Pine Fragrance Balm

4(2 ratings)
$7.50at Scalise Family Sheep FarmChecked 4 h ago
See all prices and details
Visit Scalise Family Sheep Farm
Pros
  • Alcohol-free and gentle on skin
  • Moisturizes with beeswax and coconut oil
  • No spill or leak risk in a bag
  • Subtle scent that won't overwhelm
  • Handmade in small batches
Cons
  • Shorter wear than the oil
  • Scent is quiet and may fade fast on some skin
  • Contains beeswax, so not vegan
  • Tin is not refillable

What separates them

Pine Cologne OilPine Solid Cologne
FormJojoba oil in a glass roll-onBeeswax and coconut oil balm in a tin
Scent profileResinous pine, rich woods, hint of pineappleClean, fresh pine forest, subtle
Strength and longevityVery long lasting, highly scented, a little goes a long wayLasts hours, deliberately not overpowering
Skin feelDry jojoba oil, not wetMelts in and moisturizes with natural oils
Leak and spill riskRoll-on glass bottle; can leak if the cap loosensSolid balm, no spill or leak risk
RefillableRoller top pops out and the bottle can be refilledNot refillable; replace the tin
IngredientsVegan, paraben-free, jojoba and fragranceBeeswax and coconut oil, alcohol-free, not vegan
Size10 g / .33 oz travel bottleCompact travel tin

Price history

$17.75$7.50
Nov 9Nov 21
  • Pine Cologne Oil: lowest $7.50 on Nov 9 at Amazon; $17.75 on Nov 21.

Prices at every store

Pine Cologne Oil

  • EtsyNew

    In stockSold by BerrysweetStuff

    $17.75Free shippingChecked 4 h ago
    Visit Etsy
  • Humphrey's HandmadeNew

    Availability unknownReturn policy

    $13.00Checked 4 h ago
    Visit Humphrey's Handmade
  • AmazonNew

    Availability unknown

    As an Amazon Associate, Deal.ai earns from qualifying purchases.

    $7.50+ $6.00 shippingChecked Nov 9
    Visit Amazon

Also available at

  • Humphrey's HandmadeCheck price at Humphrey's Handmade

Store links may earn us a commission.

All 3 stores and price history →

Pine Solid Cologne

  • Scalise Family Sheep FarmNew

    In stockReturn policy

    $7.50Checked 4 h ago
    Visit Scalise Family Sheep Farm
Prices and history →

Specs compared

SpecPine Cologne OilPine Solid Cologne
Bottle typere-useable BPA free glass roll-on bottles—
Base oilhigh quality jojoba oil—
Scent notesresinous pine with rich woods and pineapple—
Longevityvery long lasting—
FormOil—
DepartmentMen's—
Travel SizeYes—
VeganYes—
Paraben-FreeYes—

What reviewers say

Pine Cologne Oil

Buyers describe the scent as long-lasting, which is the point most often praised. Beyond longevity, feedback on this scent is thin.

What people mention
  • LongevityPraisedBuyers say the scent lasts a long time on the skin.

Pine Solid Cologne

Buyers describe a gentle, subtle pine scent that is not overpowering and leaves skin soft and moisturized. They rate the quality and care of the handmade balm highly.

What people mention
  • Scent strengthPraisedBuyers call the pine scent subtle and fresh rather than overpowering.
  • Skin feelPraisedBuyers say the balm is gentle on skin and leaves it soft and moisturized.
  • Build qualityPraisedBuyers describe it as excellent quality, made with care.

Questions and answers

Which lasts longer on skin?
The PINE Cologne Oil. It is described as very long lasting and highly scented, while the solid balm is built to last hours and stay subtle.
Which is better for travel?
Both travel well. The solid balm cannot spill or leak, which makes it the safer choice in a bag; the oil's glass roll-on is refillable but can leak if the cap loosens.
Is the solid balm good for sensitive or dry skin?
Yes. It is alcohol-free and made with beeswax and coconut oil, and owners say it leaves skin soft. The oil is a dry jojoba base, so it absorbs without residue but offers no moisturizing.
Are either of them vegan?
The PINE Cologne Oil is vegan and paraben-free. The solid balm uses beeswax, so it is not vegan.
Is the oil worth stepping up to over the balm?
If scent strength and longevity matter most, yes. If you want a soft, skin-friendly pine you can reapply without spill risk, the balm is the better fit.
Can I refill either one?
Only the oil. Its roller top pops out so you can refill the glass bottle. The solid balm tin is used up and replaced.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.

Enter to send, Shift+Enter for a new line

More comparisons

  • PINE Cologne Oil vs Pino Silvestre Acqua di Pino EdC
  • PINE Cologne Oil vs WENDIGO Cologne Oil
  • Pine Solid Cologne – Natural Pine Fragrance Balm vs Pino Silvestre Acqua di Pino EdC
  • Pine Solid Cologne – Natural Pine Fragrance Balm vs WENDIGO Cologne Oil

Buying guides that pick them

  • Best pine scented men's colognes under $25