Which is better for travel?

The Maybelline City Mini. It is a mini compact, while the Pinky Rose comes in a box.

Which has more product?

The Pinky Rose, at 18.6 g. Maybelline does not list a weight for the City Mini.

Is the Maybelline palette waterproof?

Yes. The Pinky Rose palette makes no waterproof claim.

Which is better for a plum evening look?

The Pinky Rose Luscious Plums, whose shades are plum-toned. The City Mini leans neutral and bronze.

Is the Maybelline worth the extra?

At $12.95 at Janets Closet as of November 7, 2026, it is the only one of the two with a listed price, and it has sold as low as $8.99.

Both are. Pinky Rose lists rose fragrance; Maybelline lists chocolate.

Pinky Rose Luscious Plums Palette vs Maybelline City Mini Palette

Buy the Maybelline City Mini if you want a small, cheap, travel-friendly palette with matte and shimmer neutrals; it is $12.95 at Janets Closet as of November 7, 2026, and has sold as low as $8.99 on that same date. Buy the Pinky Rose Luscious Plums if you want a larger 18.6 g palette with a rose scent and a plum-toned shimmer range. The Maybelline is the lower-risk buy for most shoppers; the Pinky Rose is the pick for scent and volume.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.