Which is better for tummy time and crawling?

The Plush Flannel. Its 1.5-inch slow-rebound foam gives more cushioning than the Beavtaens' 0.6 inch, which matters on hard floors.

Which fits a playpen?

The Beavtaens. It is a 50x50 square built for standard playpens. The Plush Flannel is a 3'3" x 4'11" rectangle and will not fill a square playpen.

Is the Plush Flannel worth $14 more?

If the mat sits on a hard floor and the baby spends hours on it, yes. The extra thickness and the OEKO-TEX and CPSIA certification are the reasons. If you mainly need a washable playpen liner, the Beavtaens is enough.

Which is easier to clean?

The Beavtaens. It is waterproof and machine washable. The Plush Flannel has a water-resistant surface that you wipe clean.

Both are foam mats with no long-term test data. The Beavtaens has 2,736 ratings and claims shape recovery after washing; the Plush Flannel has only 35 ratings, so there is less evidence either way.

Does either have safety certification?

The Plush Flannel lists OEKO-TEX fabric certification plus CPSIA and ASTM compliance. The Beavtaens lists none.

Plush Flannel Wide-edge Baby Play Mat 1.5" Thick vs Beavtaens Baby Play Mat, 50x50 Playpen Mat with Thick Soft Foam

Buy the Plush Flannel mat if you want a thick, soft, certified surface for a baby who spends a lot of time on the floor. Buy the Beavtaens if you need a square mat that fits a standard 50x50 playpen and costs less. The Plush Flannel is $39.99 at Amazon as of November 3, 2026, and the Beavtaens is $25.99 at Walmart as of November 3, 2026.

Today the Beavtaens Baby Play Mat, 50x50 Playpen Mat with Thick Soft Foam costs $14.00 less at its best price.

Ask our shopping agent