The Dreamer Blanket. Owners consistently describe it as cloud-like and velvety on both sides, and its stretch adds to the soft feel. The Plush Throw is soft but flatter and lighter.

Which is better for a bed?

The Dreamer. It goes up to 100"x108" for full king coverage, while the Plush Throw tops out at King in a 50"x80" size that suits a couch or a twin bed better.

Both are machine washable. The Dreamer is built to stay soft wash after wash, but it must hang dry. The Plush Throw can go in the dryer, though wool versions need gentler care.

Is the Dreamer worth stepping up to?

Yes if softness and size matter most. The Plush Throw makes more sense if you want a light, patterned throw or a wool option.

Which is better for gifting?

The Dreamer, thanks to its 20+ colorways, limited drops and broad size range. The Plush Throw is a solid gift too, especially in its patterned fleece.

Plush Throw Blanket vs Dreamer Blanket

Buy the Dreamer Blanket if you want the softest feel and the widest size range; buy the Plush Throw if you want a lighter, patterned throw that reads as decor. The Dreamer wins on stretch, size options and colorways, and its 5,764 ratings back the softness claims. The Plush Throw is lighter at 1.81 lb and comes in fleece or wool, but its size range is narrower and its rating base is far smaller.

Choose the Plush Throw Blanket if you want a lightweight patterned throw for the couch that doubles as decor and comes in a wool option.
Choose the Dreamer Blanket if you want maximum softness, four-way stretch and sizes up to full king bed coverage in 20+ colorways.

Prices

Plush Throw Blanket: $7.40 at eBay (last seen Nov 9)
Dreamer Blanket: $99.00 at Comfrt (checked today)
Difference: the Plush Throw Blanket is $91.60 cheaper than the Dreamer Blanket at the latest prices (Nov 9 and Nov 10)