Polo Ralph Lauren Classic Fit Shirt vs Old Navy Men's Heavyweight Plaid Flannel Shirt

Buy the Polo Ralph Lauren Classic Fit shirt if you want a soft, stretchy cotton button-down that works for casual wear and smart-casual occasions. Buy the Old Navy flannel if you want a warm, heavyweight plaid shirt with a chest pocket for cold weather and layering. The Polo has the stronger brand name and a more versatile solid look; the Old Navy is the better pick for warmth and rugged everyday use.

• Choose the Polo Ralph Lauren if you want a breathable, slightly stretchy cotton shirt that moves easily between casual and smart-casual wear.
• Choose the Old Navy flannel if you want a heavyweight plaid shirt with a chest pocket for cold days and layering over a tee.