Premier Protein Vanilla Shake vs Premier Protein Chocolate Shake
Both are the same Premier Protein formula in different flavors, so the choice comes down to taste and bottle size. Vanilla is the safer pick for mixing into smoothies, coffee or oatmeal, and it has 1g of sugar. Chocolate rates slightly higher with owners and comes in a larger 14 fl oz bottle, but the listing's specs are inconsistent on size and the description talks about Café Latte, not chocolate. Buyers consistently praise the thick, smooth texture and 30g of protein; the common complaints are the sweetener aftertaste and chalkiness in some batches.
- Choose the Premier Protein Vanilla if you want a neutral flavor you can blend into smoothies, coffee or oatmeal, with 1g of sugar and a 12-pack of 11 fl oz bottles.
- Choose the Premier Protein Chocolate if you want a dessert-like flavor and a bigger 14 fl oz bottle, and you don't mind 2g of sugar.
Prices
- Premier Protein Vanilla Shake: $26.74 at Walmart (checked today)
- Premier Protein Chocolate Shake: $24.99 at Strack & Van Til (last seen Nov 10)
- Difference: the Premier Protein Chocolate Shake is $1.75 cheaper than the Premier Protein Vanilla Shake at the latest prices (Nov 10 and Nov 18)

