Independent Trading Co. SS4500 Hoodie vs Gildan 18500 Hoodie

Buy the Independent Trading Co. SS4500 if you want a heavier, cotton-rich hoodie that holds its shape and takes embroidery or screen print well. Buy the Gildan 18500 if you want a lighter, softer-feeling everyday hoodie with a double-lined hood and a lower entry point. The SS4500 wins on fabric weight, cotton content and trim durability; the 18500 wins on initial softness and color range. Owners of both rate them as reliable blanks, and the SS4500's 4.6 average reflects fewer complaints about fading and pilling.

• Choose the Independent Trading Co. SS4500 if you want an 8.5 oz, 80/20 cotton hoodie that keeps its shape and takes embroidery or screen print cleanly.
• Choose the Gildan 18500 if you want a lighter, air-jet spun hoodie that feels soft from day one and comes in a wide color range.