ProSource Shapes & Colors Foam Play Mat vs ProSource 36-Piece Foam Puzzle Mat

Both are the same ProSource 36-tile EVA foam mat in a 6'x6' layout with 24 borders, so the choice comes down to surface style and packaging, not quality. The Shapes & Colors version adds printed shapes and colors for early-learning play and ships without a stated storage bag. The solid-color version has a gently textured non-slip surface and comes in a zippered bag for transport. Owners of both report sturdy, easy-to-clean tiles that hold up to daily play; the 3/8-inch high-density foam is firm enough for hard floors but will dent under heavy furniture.

• Choose the ProSource Shapes & Colors mat if you want printed shapes and colors as a teaching aid and your child is at least 3 years old.
• Choose the ProSource 36-Piece Foam Puzzle Mat if you want a plain solid-color surface, a zippered storage bag, and a mat rated 4.6 out of 5 from 271 ratings.