Protein Powder: Cookie Dough vs Protein Powder: Chocolate Peanut Butter
Buy Product B (Chocolate Peanut Butter) if you want a plant-based shake with a strong rating record; buy Product A (Cookie Dough) if you want more protein per scoop and a lower price. Product A's lowest recent price was $30.59 on 2026-10-30, against $34.99 for Product B on the same date. Product B's price swung as high as $55.00 on 2026-11-01, so check the current price before you commit.
Ask our shopping agent
Protein Powder: Cookie Dough
4.6Choose the Cookie Dough if you want 21g of protein per 30g scoop at about 103 calories and a lower entry price.
Pros
- 21g protein in a 30g scoop
- 103 calories and under 1g fat per serving
- 18 amino acids listed
- Lowest recent price was $30.59
- Narrow price range since 2026-10-30
Cons
- Contains soy
- Listing calls it vegan but the description says whey, which is dairy
- Fewer ratings than Product B
- Cookie dough flavor is sweet and polarizing
What separates them
| Protein Powder: Cookie Dough | Protein Powder: Chocolate Peanut Butter | |
|---|---|---|
| Protein source | Whey isolate per the description, though the listing also says vegan | Pea protein with peanut butter powder and MCT oil |
| Protein per serving | 21g per 30g scoop | Not stated in the listing |
| Calories per serving | 103 calories, under 1g fat, 4.5g carbs | Not stated in the listing |
| Ratings | 4.6 out of 5 from 196 ratings | 4.8 out of 5 from 460 ratings |
| Allergens | Contains soy | Contains peanut |
| Lowest recent price | $30.59 on 2026-10-30 | $34.99 on 2026-10-30 |
| Price stability | $30.59 to $32.88 since 2026-10-30 | $34.99 to $55.00 since 2026-10-30 |
Price history
$55.00$30.59
- Protein Powder: Cookie Dough: lowest $30.59 on Oct 30; $32.88 on Nov 1.
- Protein Powder: Chocolate Peanut Butter: lowest $34.99 on Oct 30 at Target; $55.00 on Nov 1.
Prices at every store
Protein Powder: Chocolate Peanut Butter
- Crystal Coast Sport ShopCheck price at Crystal Coast Sport Shop
- eBayCheck price at eBay
- Goodwin’s OrganicsCheck price at Goodwin’s Organics
Specs compared
| Spec | Protein Powder: Cookie Dough | Protein Powder: Chocolate Peanut Butter |
|---|---|---|
| Protein per serving | 21g | — |
| Serving size | 30g scoop | — |
| Carbohydrates per serving | 4.5g | — |
| Fat per serving | <1g | — |
| Calories per serving | 103 calories | — |
| Item weight | 1290 Grams | — |
| Unit count | 600.0 gram | — |
| Flavour | Cookie Dough Original 1.2kg | — |
| Diet type | Vegan | — |
| Allergen information | Contains: Soy | — |
| Package type |
Questions and answers
- Which has more protein per serving?
- Product A states 21g per 30g scoop. Product B does not list protein per serving, so you cannot compare directly from the listings.
- Which is better for a dairy-free diet?
- Product B uses pea protein, so it fits dairy-free diets. Product A's listing says vegan but its description says whey isolate, which is dairy, so confirm before buying.
- Is Product B worth the extra cost?
- At the lowest recent prices it costs $4.40 more. You get a higher rating from more than twice as many ratings and a plant-based formula, but no published macros.
- Which is cheaper right now?
- Product A's lowest recent price was $30.59 on 2026-10-30; Product B's was $34.99 the same day. Check both current prices, since Product B has hit $55.00.
- Which flavor is safer to try?
- Product B's chocolate peanut butter has a 4.8 rating from 460 ratings. Product A's cookie dough has 4.6 from 196, so Product B has more evidence behind it.
- Do either contain common allergens?
- Product A contains soy. Product B contains peanut. Pick based on which allergen you need to avoid.
