Which is better for standing all day?

The Puma Carina Mia. Its extra-thick heel and soft cushioning give more underfoot support than the LOFT's padded footbed alone.

The Puma Carina Mia. A leather upper and full rubber outsole generally hold up better than a textile upper with a rubber/plastic sole.

Is the LOFT Varsity worth buying over the Puma?

Only if you want a lighter, breathable textile sneaker and like the varsity style. The Puma rates higher and has the sturdier build.

Can I wear either for workouts?

No. Both are everyday fashion sneakers, not training shoes. Neither lists gym or running use.

Which is easier to clean?

The Puma Carina Mia. Wipe the leather-look upper clean. The LOFT's textile upper needs spot cleaning and stains set in faster.

Do both come in wide sizes?

Neither listing mentions width options. Check each store's size chart before ordering.

Puma Carina Mia Women's Sneakers vs LOFT Varsity Lace Up Women's Sneakers

The Puma Carina Mia is the safer pick for most shoppers: it has a higher rating (4.8 from 225 ratings vs 4.1 from 176), a leather-look upper, and a thick platform heel with soft cushioning. The LOFT Varsity is a lighter textile sneaker with a padded footbed and a varsity look, and it is sold online only. Compare current prices at each store before you decide, since neither price was provided here.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.