PUR PLUS Faucet Mount Water Filtration System vs Culligan Faucet Mount Water Filter
Buy the PUR PLUS if you want the widest certified reduction list and a filter-change light. Buy the Culligan if you want a simple, cheap faucet filter with a 200-gallon cartridge. No current prices were provided for either unit, so compare live store prices on this page before deciding.
Ask our shopping agent
PUR PLUS Faucet Mount Water Filtration System
4.4Choose the PUR PLUS if you want NSF/WQA certification against 70 substances including lead, plus an on/off lever and a filter-change indicator light.
Pros
- Certified to reduce 70 substances, including lead
- Filter-change light removes guesswork
- Tool-free screw-on installation
- On/off lever for filtered or unfiltered water
- Long track record as a faucet-filter brand
Cons
- Replacement filter life not stated in the specs
- Only genuine PUR filters are certified for it
- Black/chrome finish may not suit every kitchen
What separates them
| PUR PLUS Faucet Mount Water Filtration System | Culligan Faucet Mount Water Filter | |
|---|---|---|
| Certified contaminant reduction | Certified by WQA and NSF to reduce 70 chemical and physical substances, including lead | NSF International certified; specific reduction list not stated in the specs |
| Filter life | Genuine PUR PLUS replacement filter; rated life not stated in the specs | 200 gallons per cartridge |
| Filter media | 3-in-1 filtration technology | Carbon block |
| Filter change reminder | Indicator light shows when to replace the filter | Sticker reminder |
| Flow control | On/off lever switches between filtered and unfiltered water | Diverter tab |
| Installation | Threads onto the faucet, no tools needed | Faucet-mounted, plastic body |
| Finish and color | Black/chrome | White |
Price history
- PUR PLUS Faucet Mount Water Filtration System: lowest $29.99 on Oct 29 at Amazon.
- Culligan Faucet Mount Water Filter: lowest $27.49 on Oct 29 at Amazon.
Prices at every store
PUR PLUS Faucet Mount Water Filtration System
- WalmartCheck price at Walmart
- AmazonCheck price at Amazon
Culligan Faucet Mount Water Filter
- Ace Family HardwareCheck price at Ace Family Hardware
- AmazonCheck price at Amazon
- eBayCheck price at eBay
Specs compared
| Spec | PUR PLUS Faucet Mount Water Filtration System | Culligan Faucet Mount Water Filter |
|---|---|---|
| color | Black | White |
| actual_color | Black | — |
| count_per_pack | 1 | — |
| Depth | — | 4" |
| Height | — | 7" |
| Width | — | 6" |
| Installation Type | — | Faucet-mounted |
| Filtration | — | Filter |
| Water Capacity | — | 200 gal |
| Water Source | — | Tap water |
| Filter Type |
What reviewers say
PUR PLUS Faucet Mount Water Filtration System
Owners rate it well overall, with 4.4 out of 5 from 4,255 ratings. Most praise the easy install and better-tasting water; complaints center on filter life and fit on some faucets.
Pros
- Simple, tool-free installation
- Noticeably better-tasting water
- Clear filter-change light
- Compact horizontal design
Cons
- Filters run out faster than expected
- Doesn't fit some faucet styles
- Reduced flow when filtering
Culligan Faucet Mount Water Filter
Owners generally find it easy to install and effective at improving the taste and smell of chlorinated tap water. Complaints center on slow flow and the unit getting in the way at the sink.
Pros
Questions and answers
- Which removes more contaminants, PUR PLUS or Culligan?
- PUR PLUS, on paper. It is certified by WQA and NSF to reduce 70 substances including lead. The Culligan is NSF certified, but its specs do not list which contaminants it reduces.
- Which filter lasts longer?
- The Culligan cartridge is rated for 200 gallons. PUR does not state a filter life for the PLUS in the specs, so check the replacement filter listing for its rated capacity.
- Is the PUR PLUS worth extra money?
- If lead and a broad reduction list matter to you, yes. If you just want basic carbon-block filtering and a known 200-gallon life, the Culligan covers that for less.
- Do either need tools to install?
- No. Both are faucet-mounted. The PUR threads on by hand, and the Culligan mounts the same way with a diverter tab.
- How fast do they dispense water?
- The Culligan is rated at 0.5 gallons per minute. PUR does not state a flow rate in the specs.
- Can I use any replacement filter?
- For the PUR PLUS, use genuine PUR PLUS faucet-mount filters; PUR says only those are certified for the unit. For the Culligan, use Culligan cartridges made for this model.