Which is warmer in freezing weather?

The Pioneer Camp, based on its cotton filling plus heat-storage layer and windproof cuffs and collar. The Purcolt lists polyester fill with no heat-storage layer.

Which one keeps you dry in rain?

The Pioneer Camp. Its shell has a DWR coating; the Purcolt page states only a polyester shell with no water-repellent finish.

Which has more sizes?

The Purcolt, which lists M through 5XL. The Pioneer Camp page does not state a size range, so check the size chart before ordering.

Is the Pioneer Camp worth extra money?

If it costs more, you pay for the waterproof shell, heat-storage lining and two-way zipper. If you only need a long coat for dry cold and want a 3XL or larger, the Purcolt is enough.

Which is better for hiking or skiing?

The Pioneer Camp. The two-way zipper, ribbed cuffs and water-repellent shell suit movement and wet snow better than the Purcolt's plain zip design.

How do the pockets compare?

The Pioneer Camp has three: large hand-warmer pockets and one inner zippered pocket. The Purcolt says multi pockets but does not give a count.

Purcolt Men's Long Winter Coat vs Men's Waterproof Long Winter Puffer Coat

Buy the Pioneer Camp long puffer if you need real weather protection: its DWR-coated shell, ribbed cuffs and two-way zipper handle rain, wind and movement. The Purcolt is a plain polyester zip-up that comes in black, gray or army green and sizes up to 5XL, so it suits shoppers who want a cheap long coat in a hard-to-find size. Neither listing shows a price, so compare live store prices before you commit.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.