Thursday Boot Company Racer Jacket vs House of Leather Anna Biker Jacket

The Anna is the better pick for most shoppers: a women's cross-zip biker in soft sheep nappa with quilting at the waist, cuffs and shoulders, and a much larger review base. The Racer is a plainer banded-collar lambskin jacket with a lifetime-guaranteed main zipper and hidden interior pockets, and its 4.9 rating comes from far fewer owners. Build is close on paper; the Anna's known weakness is sizing, since several reviewers had to go up a size.

• Choose the Racer Jacket if you want a clean banded-collar lambskin jacket with a lifetime-guaranteed zipper and hidden inside pockets.
• Choose the Anna if you want a women's cross-zip biker with quilting detail and a soft, broken-in sheep nappa feel.