Ralph Lauren Ralph's Club New York vs Versace Man Eau Fraîche EDT

Ralph's Club is the richer, warmer choice: an eau de parfum built on blackcurrant, lavender and sandalwood, with a chrome bottle that feels more substantial. Versace Man Eau Fraîche is the lighter, fresher eau de toilette, a citrus-woody aquatic that suits heat and daytime wear. Owners of Ralph's Club praise its longevity and smooth drydown; Eau Fraîche fans like its clean freshness but often note it fades within a few hours. Buy Ralph's Club for evening and cool-weather wear, Eau Fraîche for summer and the office.

• Choose the Ralph's Club if you want a warm, woody eau de parfum with stronger projection and better staying power for evenings and colder months.
• Choose the Versace Eau Fraîche if you want a light, clean citrus-aquatic scent for hot days, the gym or a shared office.