Razor EcoSmart Metro HD vs Hiboy Q2/U2 Electric Scooter with Seat
The Hiboy Q2/U2 is the better buy for most riders: more range, more speed, dual brakes and suspension, and a seat with a basket. The Razor EcoSmart Metro HD is simpler and sturdier in frame but slower, shorter-range and heavier, with only a rear hand brake. No current prices were provided for either scooter, so check live store prices on Deal.ai before deciding.
Ask our shopping agent
Razor EcoSmart Metro HD
Choose the Razor EcoSmart Metro HD if you want a proven Razor-brand seated scooter with a steel frame and a simple rear hand brake for short, flat neighborhood trips.
- Larger 16-inch pneumatic tires roll over bumps well
- Steel frame is durable and simple
- Razor brand with wide parts availability
- Rear hub motor needs little maintenance
- Only 12 miles of range
- 15.5 mph top speed is slow for traffic
- 72.89 lb is very heavy to lift or store
- Sealed lead-acid battery is heavy and ages faster than lithium
What separates them
| Razor EcoSmart Metro HD | Hiboy Q2/U2 Electric Scooter with Seat | |
|---|---|---|
| Top speed | Up to 15.5 mph | Up to 20 mph |
| Range | Up to 12 miles | Up to 25 miles |
| Motor | 350W brushless rear hub | 422W rated, 527W peak |
| Battery | 36V sealed lead-acid | 36V 10.4Ah lithium |
| Brakes | Rear hand brake only | Front and rear drum |
| Suspension | None listed | Front and rear |
| Wheels | 16-inch pneumatic | 14-inch pneumatic tubed |
| Weight | 72.89 lb |
Price history
- Razor EcoSmart Metro HD: lowest $494.89 on Oct 31 at Amazon.
- Hiboy Q2/U2 Electric Scooter with Seat: lowest $459.99 on Oct 31 at Carolina Sportsman Outfitters.
Prices at every store
Hiboy Q2/U2 Electric Scooter with Seat
- AmazonCheck price at Amazon
- Carolina Sportsman OutfittersCheck price at Carolina Sportsman Outfitters
Specs compared
| Spec | Razor EcoSmart Metro HD | Hiboy Q2/U2 Electric Scooter with Seat |
|---|---|---|
| Range | Up to 12 miles (19 km) | 25 mi |
| Max speed | Up to 15.5 mph (25 km/h) | — |
| Run time | Up to 60 minutes | — |
| Motor | 350-watt, variable-speed, high-torque, brushles… | — |
| Battery | 36V (three 12V) sealed lead-acid, rechargeable | — |
| Max rider weight | 220 lb (100 kg) | — |
| Product weight | 72.89 lbs (33.13 kg) | — |
| Front wheel | Spoked with 16” (406 mm), pneumatic tire | — |
| Rear tire | 16” (406 mm), pneumatic | — |
| Brake | Hand-operated, rear | — |
What reviewers say
Razor EcoSmart Metro HD
Owners treat the EcoSmart Metro HD as a comfortable, sturdy seated scooter for short trips. Most praise the ride and the big tires; the recurring complaints are weight, lead-acid battery life and range that falls short of the claim.
- Comfortable seat and upright riding position
- Smooth ride from 16-inch pneumatic tires
- Sturdy steel build that feels safe
- Simple controls and easy assembly
- Very heavy to lift or store
- Lead-acid battery degrades and is costly to replace
- Real-world range often below 12 miles
- Slow acceleration from a stop
Hiboy Q2/U2 Electric Scooter with Seat
Owners describe the U2 as comfortable, durable and fun, with solid battery life and speed. The main gripes are vague assembly instructions and recurring rear tire tube problems.
Questions and answers
- Which is better for a daily commute?
- The Hiboy Q2/U2. It has double the range, a 20 mph top speed, dual drum brakes and suspension, which matter on longer rides.
- Which lasts longer on a charge?
- The Hiboy, at up to 25 miles versus up to 12 miles for the Razor. Real range drops with rider weight, hills and speed.
- Is the Razor worth it for short trips?
- Yes, if your trips are under about 10 miles on flat ground. Its 16-inch tires and steel frame are simple and sturdy, but it is slow and very heavy.
- Which is easier to store and carry?
- The Hiboy folds and is the lighter class of the two. The Razor weighs 72.89 lb and does not list a folding mechanism.
- Which has better brakes?
- The Hiboy. It has front and rear drum brakes; the Razor has only a hand-operated rear brake.
- Do both have a seat?
- Yes, both are seated scooters. The Hiboy adds an extra-thick padded seat and a rear basket.