REI Co-op 650 Down Jacket vs Pioneer Camp Men's 700-Fill Down Jacket

The Pioneer Camp is the warmer, more weather-ready jacket: 700-fill hydrophobic down, a hood, a graphene-lined back panel and a 14°F rating. The REI 650 is lighter and simpler, with no hood, a roomy relaxed cut and a longer track record of owner feedback. Build quality is close on paper, but the REI's 248 ratings give a steadier read than the Pioneer Camp's 29. Buy the Pioneer Camp for real winter cold and wet weather; buy the REI for mild fall hiking and layering.

• Choose the REI Co-op 650 Down Jacket if you want a light, roomy layer for fall hiking and everyday wear in dry, cool conditions.
• Choose the Pioneer Camp Down Jacket if you need a hooded, water-repellent puffer for freezing, damp winter weather.