Which is better for hot weather?

The Duchie. Merino wool breathes and manages moisture better than a viscose-polyester blend, and the open collar adds airflow.

The Duchie's merino holds shape and resists odor well, but it needs gentle washing. The Rothwell's viscose blend can stretch and pills with rough wear, and it is hand wash only.

Is the Rothwell worth $30 more?

Only if you want the slim fit and contrast tipping. On fabric and price, the Duchie is the better buy at $55 versus $85.

Can I wear the Duchie to the office?

Yes, in casual offices. The open collar reads more relaxed than a buttoned polo, so it suits smart-casual rather than formal settings.

The Rothwell, which is cut slim. The Duchie is roomier; the listed piece measures 22 inches across the chest and 28.5 inches long.

Hand wash the Rothwell. Wash the Duchie gently in cool water or dry clean it to protect the wool.

Reiss Mens Short Sleeve Polo Shirt vs REISS Duchie Short Sleeve Open Collar Merino Polo Shirt

Buy the Duchie if you want merino wool and a lower price: $55 at RefindNYC by Housing Works as of November 5, 2026, versus $85 at Reiss for the Rothwell. Buy the Rothwell if you want a slim viscose-blend knit with contrast tipping and don't mind hand washing. The Duchie is the better value on fabric and price; the Rothwell is the more polished, dressier knit.

Today the REISS Duchie Short Sleeve Open Collar Merino Polo Shirt costs $30.00 less at its best price.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.