Revlon ColorSilk vs L'Oréal Paris Excellence Creme

Both are permanent, ammonia-free-leaning drugstore dyes with 100% gray coverage, but they suit different shoppers. ColorSilk has a far larger shade range, a bond-repair and keratin story, and a much stronger owner record at 4.6 from over 54,000 ratings. Excellence Creme leans on a three-step care routine with hyaluronic acid and a leave-in mask, but its 3.7 rating from 900 reviews suggests more mixed results. Pick ColorSilk for shade choice and proven satisfaction; pick Excellence if you want the pre-and-post conditioning ritual.

• Choose the Revlon ColorSilk if you want the widest shade range, a bond-repair and keratin formula, and the most consistently well-rated at-home dye.
• Choose the L'Oréal Excellence Creme if you want a multi-step care routine with a hyaluronic acid mask and a non-drip creme that refreshes roots on previously colored hair.