Which is better for driving lag screws and deck screws?

The Ridgid R862312, on paper. It delivers 2,400 in-lbs against the Milwaukee's 2,000 in-lbs, and its self-tapping mode stops the tool once the screw seats. The Milwaukee is faster but has less peak torque.

Which is better for cabinet and finish work?

The Milwaukee 2953. Its Ultimate Trigger Control gives smoother acceleration on small screws, and at 4.5 in. it fits where the 5.0 in. Ridgid will not.

Is the Milwaukee worth the extra money?

Only if you need the speed, the shorter body or the trigger control. The Ridgid has more torque and a lifetime service agreement, so the premium buys refinement, not raw power.

Which one lasts longer?

The Ridgid's Lifetime Service Agreement covers free batteries, parts and service for life once you register within 90 days. The Milwaukee carries a 3-year tool warranty and a 2-year battery warranty.

Do they use the same batteries?

No. The Ridgid runs on Ridgid 18V batteries and the Milwaukee on M18 packs. Neither bare tool includes a battery, so the platform you already own should decide it.

How do their weights compare?

Nearly identical. The Ridgid is 2.3 lbs bare and the Milwaukee 2.2 lbs bare, and tested weights come out at 4.5 lbs and 4.6 lbs.

Ridgid 18V Brushless R862312 vs Milwaukee M18 Fuel 2953

Both are 18V brushless 1/4 in. impact drivers with 4-mode control and a self-tapping mode, and both are rated 4.6 out of 5. The Ridgid R862312 wins on peak torque at 2,400 in-lbs and on warranty, with its Lifetime Service Agreement covering batteries, parts and service for life after registration. The Milwaukee 2953 wins on speed, size and trigger control, at 3,900 RPM and 4.5 in. long. Pick the Ridgid for heavy lag and deck work on a budget; pick the Milwaukee for cabinet and finish work where control and reach matter.

Ask our shopping agent