Rockwool Comfortbatt R-23 Stone Wool Insulation vs ROCKWOOL Safe'n'Sound
Buy ComfortBatt R-23 if you need thermal insulation for 2x6 exterior walls, attics or crawlspaces. Buy Safe'n'Sound if your main goal is quieting interior rooms. ComfortBatt is the thermal product: R-23 in a 5.5-inch batt that fits 24-inch stud spacing, noncombustible, water resistant and ENERGY STAR certified. Safe'n'Sound is a sound product: 3-inch batts, NRC 1.05, flame spread and smoke index of 0, but it carries no R-value claim, so it is a poor choice for exterior walls. Owners of both praise the friction fit and the way stone wool holds its shape; the common complaint about ComfortBatt is the itch and dust when cutting, and about Safe'n'Sound that it is sold for sound, not heat.
- Choose the ComfortBatt R-23 if you are insulating exterior 2x6 walls, an attic or a crawlspace and need a real R-value plus fire and moisture resistance.
- Choose the Safe'n'Sound if you are soundproofing interior partitions, ceilings or floors between rooms and thermal performance is not the job.
Prices
- Rockwool Comfortbatt R-23 Stone Wool Insulation: $95.67 at Lowe's (checked today)
- ROCKWOOL Safe'n'Sound: $65.00 at Years Building Materials (last seen Nov 9)
- Difference: the ROCKWOOL Safe'n'Sound is $30.67 cheaper than the Rockwool Comfortbatt R-23 Stone Wool Insulation at the latest prices (Nov 9 and Nov 21)

