Roll-Away Shikibuton Mattress vs Takaokaya Shiki Futon Mattress

The Roll-Away Shikibuton is the practical pick for most people: it rolls up with straps, comes in cot through queen sizes, and has a foam core that holds its shape. The Takaokaya Shiki Futon is the better choice if you want a hand-quilted, all-cotton futon made in Kyoto and sleep on the floor full time. The Roll-Away is firmer and easier to store; the Shiki Futon is plusher and more carefully made, but only comes in one size and does not roll.

• Choose the Roll-Away Shikibuton if you need a guest bed, dorm mattress or travel futon that rolls up, straps shut and comes in several sizes.
• Choose the Shiki Futon if you want a handmade all-cotton futon for nightly floor sleeping and prefer a plusher feel over portability.