Roper Hampton Black Suede Mule vs Quoddy Women's Moxie Mule

The Roper Hampton is the safer pick for most shoppers: a simple black suede mule with a padded lining, a flexible TPR sole and contrast stitching that reads as Western rather than sneaker. The Moxie Mule is the more distinctive shoe, with hand-sewn moccasin construction, a tassel upper and a resolable build, but its own listing is inconsistent about materials, calling the upper cotton twill in the specs and suede in the description. Owners of moccasin-built mules tend to praise the leather lining and repairability; the Roper wins on easy care and a lower-profile look.

• Choose the Roper Hampton if you want a clean black suede slip-on with a cushioned lining and a flexible sole for everyday wear.
• Choose the Moxie Mule if you want a hand-sewn, resolable moccasin-style mule and like the tassel look in mushroom suede.