Rough Country RS4500SA UTV Winch vs SuperATV 4500 lb Black Ops Winch

Both are 4,500 lb UTV/ATV winches with 50 ft synthetic rope, 166:1 gearing, wireless and wired controls, and hawse fairleads, so the pull is a wash. The Rough Country uses a 1.4 hp series-wound motor and a 4.87" x 3" bolt pattern; the SuperATV uses a 1.3 hp permanent-magnet motor, waterproof seals and solenoid, and a 3.0" x 6.6" bolt pattern. Buy the SuperATV if you ride deep mud or water and want the stronger sealing claim; buy the Rough Country if you want the slightly stronger motor and a compact footprint. Owners of both report solid pulls for their size, but neither is a fast line-speed winch.

• Choose the Rough Country RS4500SA if you want the higher-rated 1.4 hp motor, a compact 12.8-inch body, and a standard 4.87" x 3" bolt pattern that fits many UTV mounts.
• Choose the SuperATV 4500 if you ride wet or muddy terrain and want waterproof seals and solenoid plus a 50 ft wireless remote range.