Classic Yellow Rubber Duck vs Narwhal Rubber Duck

Buy the classic yellow duck if you want the familiar bath toy and the lower starting age. Buy the narwhal if you want a larger, more distinctive toy and a gift for an ocean fan or collector. Both have sealed bottoms that keep water and mold out, and both are lead- and phthalate-free. The yellow duck is the smaller, simpler pick; the narwhal is bigger and built from BPA-free plastic, but it is aimed at slightly older children.

• Choose the classic yellow duck if you want the standard bath duck for a toddler around 18 months and up.
• Choose the narwhal duck if you want a bigger, collectible sea-creature toy for a child 2 or older or as a gift.