Black FridayDealsBuying guidesBrandsStoresTermsPrivacydeal.ai apps

© Deal.ai Inc.

Deal.ai › Compare

Rubbermaid Roughneck Storage Tote vs Sterilite Plastic Stacking FlipTop Latching Storage Box, 6 Pack

Buy the Rubbermaid Roughneck for garage, attic or basement storage of bulky items like clothing, linens and sports gear. Buy the Sterilite FlipTop six-pack for small items on shelves and desks, like office supplies, crafts and accessories. The two are not close in size, so the choice is about what you are storing, not which brand is better. No current prices were provided for either product, so compare live store prices on Deal.ai before buying.

Ask our shopping agent

Enter to send, Shift+Enter for a new line

Rubbermaid
Rubbermaid Roughneck Storage Tote

Rubbermaid Roughneck Storage Tote

4.5· 478 ratings

Choose the Rubbermaid Roughneck if you need one large, weather-resistant 18-gallon tote for seasonal items, gear or linens in a garage, attic or basement.

Pros
  • Large 18-gallon capacity holds clothing, linens and sports gear
  • Weather-resistant polyethylene tolerates extreme temperatures
Airtight fitted lid keeps out moisture, dirt and bugs
  • Recessed lid stacks and attached handles make carrying easier
  • 4.5 out of 5 from 478 ratings
    • Cons
    • Opaque body, so you cannot see contents without opening
    • One large box is awkward to move when full
    • No small compartments for tiny items
    Sterilite
    Sterilite Plastic Stacking FlipTop Latching Storage Box, 6 Pack

    Sterilite Plastic Stacking FlipTop Latching Storage Box, 6 Pack

    4.5· 454 ratings

    Choose the Sterilite FlipTop six-pack if you want several small clear latching boxes for office supplies, crafts or accessories you need to see and reach quickly.

    Pros
    • Six clear boxes let you see contents at a glance
    • Latching FlipTop lids are quick to open and close
    • Small 7.6-inch footprint fits shelves and desk drawers
    • No assembly required
    • 4.5 out of 5 from 454 ratings
    Cons
    • Not water resistant, so keep away from damp areas
    • Each box holds little, at 1.7 cu ft total for six
    • Latches are not airtight, so no protection from dust or bugs
    • Too small for clothing, linens or gear

    What separates them

    Rubbermaid Roughneck Storage ToteSterilite Plastic Stacking FlipTop Latching Storage Box, 6 Pack
    Capacity18 gallons (72 qt) in one box1.7 cu ft total across six small boxes
    FootprintLarge single tote, roughly the size of a laundry basketAbout 7.6 inches square and 4.5 inches tall per box
    Weather resistanceWeather-resistant polyethylene, handles extreme temperature changesNot water resistant
    ClosureFitted lid with airtight seal against moisture, dirt and bugsFlipTop lid with latches, not sealed
    VisibilityOpaque dark indigo metallic bodyClear body, contents visible without opening
    StackingRecessed lid allows stacking several totesStackable small boxes, six in the pack
    PortabilityAttached handles for carryingSmall and light, easy to lift one at a time
    Best useBulky, long-term storage in garage, attic or basementSmall items in office, craft room or closet

    Price history

    • Rubbermaid Roughneck Storage Tote: lowest $19.99 on Oct 30 at MCS Home Center.
    • Sterilite Plastic Stacking FlipTop Latching Storage Box, 6 Pack: lowest $76.99 on Oct 30 at Wayfair.

    Prices at every store

    Rubbermaid Roughneck Storage Tote

    • MCS Home CenterCheck price at MCS Home Center
    • AmazonCheck price at Amazon
    • ImperialSupplies.comCheck price at ImperialSupplies.com
    Prices and history →

    Sterilite Plastic Stacking FlipTop Latching Storage Box, 6 Pack

    • WayfairCheck price at Wayfair
    Prices and history →

    Specs compared

    SpecRubbermaid Roughneck Storage ToteSterilite Plastic Stacking FlipTop Latching Storage Box, 6 Pack
    StackableYesYes
    colorSilverClear
    TypeLidded Box—
    Capacity72 qt capacity—
    size18 gal—
    actual_colorDark Indigo Metallic—
    Depth—7.63 inches
    Height—4.5 in
    Length—7 5/8"
    Width—7.63 inches
    Container Type—Storage Box
    Subtype—Stackable box
    Show all 28 specsShow fewer specs
    SpecRubbermaid Roughneck Storage ToteSterilite Plastic Stacking FlipTop Latching Storage Box, 6 Pack
    Material—Plastic
    Finish—White
    Collapsible—No
    Dividers—No
    Wheels—No
    Assembly Required—No
    Closure Type—Latching, Lid
    Lid Type—FlipTop
    Volume Capacity—1.7 cu ft
    Weight Capacity—

    What reviewers say

    Rubbermaid Roughneck Storage Tote

    Owners rate it 4.5 out of 5 across 478 ratings, and the pattern is consistent: sturdy bins that stack and survive garage temperature swings. Complaints center on lids that don't lock down and bins arriving cracked.

    Pros
    • Thick walls that hold up in garages and attics
    • Stacks well without collapsing
    • Handles make carrying full bins manageable
    • Lid keeps dust and moisture out
    Cons
    • Lid can come loose when a full bin is dropped
    • Some units arrive cracked or split at the rim
    • Heavy once filled with tools or gear

    Sterilite Plastic Stacking FlipTop Latching Storage Box, 6 Pack

    Ratings average 4.5 out of 5 from 454 ratings, which points to broad satisfaction with these boxes for light organization. Owners of similar Sterilite flip-top boxes generally like the clear view and secure latch.

    Pros
    • Clear plastic makes contents easy to find
    • Lids latch securely
    • Stack neatly and stay aligned
    Cons
    • Smaller than some buyers expect
    • Plastic can crack if dropped or overloaded

    Questions and answers

    Which is better for garage storage?
    The Rubbermaid Roughneck. Its 18-gallon weather-resistant body and airtight lid suit temperature swings, moisture and dust in a garage. The Sterilite boxes are not water resistant and hold only small items.
    Which is better for office supplies?
    The Sterilite FlipTop six-pack. Clear bodies and small size let you sort pens, clips and accessories on a shelf or desk. The Roughneck is one large opaque tote, too big for desk items.
    Which lasts longer?
    Both are plastic and rated 4.5 out of 5, but the Roughneck is built for harsh conditions with weather-resistant polyethylene and a sealed lid. The Sterilite boxes are lighter duty and best kept indoors and dry.
    Can I stack them?
    Yes, both stack. The Roughneck has a recessed lid so several totes nest on top of each other. The Sterilite boxes stack too, but each is small, so a stack holds far less.
    Is the Sterilite set worth it over one big tote?
    Only if you need several small, visible containers. For bulky or long-term storage, one Roughneck holds much more and protects it better. Check current prices on Deal.ai to compare cost per unit of space.
    Will the Sterilite boxes keep out moisture?
    No. They are listed as not water resistant, and the FlipTop latches are not airtight. Use the Roughneck for damp garages, attics or basements.

    More comparisons

    • Sterilite 66 Quart Clear Storage Tote with Latching Lid vs Rubbermaid Roughneck Storage Tote
    • Sterilite 66 Quart Clear Storage Tote with Latching Lid vs Sterilite Plastic Stacking FlipTop Latching Storage Box, 6 Pack
    0 lb
    Suitable Items—Office supplies, Accessories, Crafts, School su…
    Shape—Rectangle
    Style—Modern
    Water Resistance—Not Water Resistant
    Storage Location—Office
    Typical Users—Adult