Which is warmer for a cold commute?

The Whole Shebang. Its vegan down fill, stand-up collar and knit storm cuffs seal the wrists and neck, which matters more than fill alone on a windy walk. The Rutainlusire is a shorter casual layer.

Which one lasts longer?

The Whole Shebang shows sturdier details: storm cuffs, an interior pocket and a detachable hood that reduces wear on the trim. The Rutainlusire is simpler, and its snap placket is the part most likely to loosen over time.

Is the detachable hood worth stepping up for?

Yes if you wear the coat in varied weather. You can strip the faux fur and hood for a cleaner look or dry days. The Rutainlusire's hood is fixed.

Which fits a curvier or larger frame?

The Rutainlusire, which runs to XXXL with a bust up to about 46 inches. The Whole Shebang's shown range is narrower, so check its size chart first.

Which is better for travel?

The Rutainlusire packs smaller as a short puffer. The Whole Shebang is the better daily coat but takes more room in a bag.

Do either have pockets that close securely?

Only The Whole Shebang has an interior pocket for a phone or keys. Both have two open side hand pockets.

Rutainlusire Hooded Puffer Jacket vs The Whole Shebang Women's Puffer Coat

The Whole Shebang is the better-built coat: detachable faux-fur hood, interior pocket, knit storm cuffs and a 4.4 rating from 60 owners back it up. The Rutainlusire is a plainer short puffer with a zip-and-snap front and side pockets, and it runs in larger sizes up to XXXL. Buy The Whole Shebang for a daily winter coat you will wear hard; buy the Rutainlusire if you want a cropped, casual layer and need a bigger size.

Choose the Rutainlusire if you want a short, cropped puffer in a casual cut and need sizes up to XXXL.
Choose The Whole Shebang if you want a detachable fur-trim hood, an interior pocket and storm cuffs for daily cold-weather wear.

Prices

Rutainlusire Hooded Puffer Jacket: $10.99 at eBay (last seen Nov 8)
The Whole Shebang Women's Puffer Coat: $26.99 at Walmart (last seen Nov 10)
Difference: the Rutainlusire Hooded Puffer Jacket is $16.00 cheaper than the The Whole Shebang Women's Puffer Coat at the latest prices (Nov 8 and Nov 10)

Rutainlusire Women's Hooded Puffer Jacket, Zip and Snap Front Winter Coat with Faux Fur Trim and Pockets, Warm Short Outerwear for Cold Weather

	Rutainlusire Hooded Puffer Jacket	The Whole Shebang Women's Puffer Coat
Length	Short, cropped at about 22 inches	Standard coat length
Hood	Attached hood with faux fur trim	Fully detachable faux-fur trimmed hood
Closure	Zip plus snap front	Full zip front with stand-up collar
Pockets	Two side pockets	Two side pockets plus a secure interior pocket
Cuffs	Standard sleeve cuffs	Knit rib storm cuffs that seal the wrist
Fill	Polyester fill	Vegan down fill in a quilted polyester shell
Size range	M through XXXL	S and up, narrower range shown
Owner feedback	No rating history	4.4 out of 5 from 60 ratings

Spec	Rutainlusire Hooded Puffer Jacket	The Whole Shebang Women's Puffer Coat
color	Black	Red
actual_color	Black	Burgundy
clothing_size	M	S
size	M	S

Rutainlusire Hooded Puffer Jacket vs The Whole Shebang Women's Puffer Coat

Prices

Rutainlusire Hooded Puffer Jacket vs The Whole Shebang Women's Puffer Coat

Prices

Rutainlusire Hooded Puffer Jacket

The Whole Shebang Women's Puffer Coat

What separates them

Prices at every store

Rutainlusire Hooded Puffer Jacket

The Whole Shebang Women's Puffer Coat

Specs compared

What reviewers say

The Whole Shebang Women's Puffer Coat

Questions and answers

Ask our shopping agent

Buying guides that pick them