RYDCOT Men's Hooded Quilted Parka vs USNSM Long Hooded Puffer Jacket

Both are budget long padded winter coats from small online brands, and neither has a track record you can lean on. The RYDCOT is the more conventional men's knee-length parka: quilted, windproof, full zip, side pockets. The USNSM is the looser unisex over-knee puffer, and its own listing says it is waterproof and that it runs small, so size up. Pick on fit and waterproofing, not on brand reputation.

• Choose the RYDCOT if you want a straightforward men's knee-length quilted parka with a full zip and deep side pockets, and you prefer a closer, more standard fit.
• Choose the USNSM if you want a looser, longer over-knee puffer that is listed as waterproof and windproof, and you are willing to size up one or two sizes.