Ryobi ONE+ 18V PCL515 Reciprocating Saw vs Makita 18V LXT Sub-Compact Recipro Saw Kit

The Makita is the better saw for most buyers. It is brushless, comes as a kit with a battery, charger and two blades, and adds a work light. The Ryobi is a bare tool on the huge ONE+ battery platform, so it only makes sense if you already own Ryobi 18V batteries. Owners rate the Ryobi well for light cutting, but the Makita's brushless motor and compact body suit harder and overhead work.

• Choose the Ryobi ONE+ PCL515 if you already own Ryobi 18V batteries and want a light saw for occasional pruning, PVC and demolition cuts.
• Choose the Makita Sub-Compact kit if you want a ready-to-run saw with a brushless motor, a work light and a compact body for tight or overhead cuts.