DealsBuying guidesBrandsStoresTermsPrivacydeal.ai apps

© Deal.ai Inc.

Deal.ai › Compare

RYOBI P884 18V ONE+ 6-Tool Combo Kit vs BLACK+DECKER 20V MAX MATRIX 6-Tool

Buy the RYOBI P884 if you want real power and a battery platform that grows with you; it costs about $279 versus roughly $130 to $150 for the BLACK+DECKER 20V MAX MATRIX 6-Tool. The BLACK+DECKER is the better pick for light household jobs and tight budgets. The price gap is roughly double, so decide based on how hard you will use the tools.

Ask our shopping agent

Enter to send, Shift+Enter for a new line

RYOBI
RYOBI P884 18V ONE+ 6-Tool Combo Kit

RYOBI P884 18V ONE+ 6-Tool Combo Kit

Choose the RYOBI P884 if you plan to build, remodel or work the tools hard and want a brushed-motor kit with a 1,600 in-lb impact driver and a 1/2-inch chuck drill.

Pros
  • Two 18V batteries included, so one can charge while you work
  • 1,600 in-lb impact driver handles lag bolts and deck screws
  • 1/2-inch chuck drill takes standard bits
ONE+ is one of the largest cordless platforms, with many bare tools sold separately
Cons
  • Costs about twice the BLACK+DECKER
  • 1.5 Ah batteries are small and drain fast in the circular and reciprocating saws
  • Brushed motors wear faster than brushless
  • Heavier and bulkier for overhead work
BLACK+DECKER
BLACK+DECKER 20V MAX MATRIX 6-Tool

BLACK+DECKER 20V MAX MATRIX 6-Tool

Choose the BLACK+DECKER 20V MAX MATRIX if you want six tools for occasional home fixes at about half the price and like the MATRIX system that swaps tool heads onto one base.

Pros
  • About $130 to $150 for six tools
  • MATRIX system lets you swap tool heads onto one base
  • Case included
  • Light and simple for occasional household repairs
Cons
  • No published torque, speed or chuck specs
  • 20V MAX batteries fit fewer third-party tools than RYOBI ONE+
  • Small batteries and light motors limit sustained saw use
  • Not built for daily or jobsite use

What separates them

RYOBI P884 18V ONE+ 6-Tool Combo KitBLACK+DECKER 20V MAX MATRIX 6-Tool
Price$279.00 low, $298.96 high since October 29, 2026$130.31 low, $149.99 high since October 29, 2026
Battery platform18V ONE+ Li-Ion, 2 batteries included, 1.5 Ah20V MAX Li-Ion, battery count not stated
Tool count6 tools6 tools
Impact driver torque1,600 in-lbs, 0-3,200 RPMNot published
Drill1/2-inch chuck, 0-440 and 0-1,600 RPM, brushed motorNot published
Circular saw4,700 RPM no-loadNot published
Reciprocating saw0-3,100 SPMNot published
CaseNot statedCase included

Price history

$298.96$130.31
Oct 29Nov 1
  • RYOBI P884 18V ONE+ 6-Tool Combo Kit: lowest $279.00 on Oct 30 at Amazon; $285.09 on Nov 1.
  • BLACK+DECKER 20V MAX MATRIX 6-Tool: lowest $130.31 on Oct 29; $149.99 on Oct 30.

Prices at every store

RYOBI P884 18V ONE+ 6-Tool Combo Kit

  • AmazonCheck price at Amazon
Prices and history →

BLACK+DECKER 20V MAX MATRIX 6-Tool

  • AmazonCheck price at Amazon
  • Black+DeckerCheck price at Black+Decker
  • eBayCheck price at eBay
Prices and history →

Specs compared

SpecRYOBI P884 18V ONE+ 6-Tool Combo KitBLACK+DECKER 20V MAX MATRIX 6-Tool
Battery voltage18 V20 volts
Battery typeLithium-Ion (Li-Ion)Lithium-ion
Number of tools66 piece
ModelP1819UPC: 33287186259—
Battery amp hours1.5 Ah—
Batteries included2—
Motor typeBrushed—
Drill no load speed0-440 / 0-1600 RPM—
Drill chuck size1/2"—
Circular saw no load speed4700 RPM—
Impact driver torque1600-inch lbs.—
Impact driver no load speed0-3200 RPM—
Show all 14 specsShow fewer specs
SpecRYOBI P884 18V ONE+ 6-Tool Combo KitBLACK+DECKER 20V MAX MATRIX 6-Tool
Reciprocating saw speed0-3,100 SPM—
Case Included—Yes

What reviewers say

RYOBI P884 18V ONE+ 6-Tool Combo Kit

Owners of RYOBI ONE+ kits generally describe them as good value for occasional home use, with the impact driver and drill drawing the most praise. Complaints center on battery runtime and on saws feeling underpowered in thick or wet lumber.

Pros
  • Impact driver has surprising torque for the price
  • Batteries interchange across the whole ONE+ line
  • Light enough for overhead and one-handed work
Cons
  • 1.5 Ah packs run down quickly in saws
  • Recip saw bogs down in thick material
  • Brushed motors and plastic chucks feel less durable than pro brands

BLACK+DECKER 20V MAX MATRIX 6-Tool

Owners generally treat the MATRIX set as a convenient light-duty kit for home fixes. Praise centers on the shared battery and the case; complaints focus on power limits and the single battery.

Pros
  • Handy for quick household repairs
  • Battery swaps across all the tools
  • Compact case keeps everything organized
Cons
  • Stalls on tough materials like thick lumber
  • One battery means downtime while charging
  • Heads can feel less solid than standalone tools

Questions and answers

Which is better for a homeowner doing occasional repairs?
The BLACK+DECKER. It covers drilling, cutting and sanding for about half the price, and the MATRIX heads keep the kit compact. Step up to the RYOBI only if you take on bigger projects.
Is the RYOBI worth the extra money?
Yes if you will use the impact driver and saws regularly. The 1,600 in-lb driver, 1/2-inch chuck and 4,700 RPM saw are real working tools, and ONE+ batteries carry over to many other tools.
Which has more power?
The RYOBI. Its impact driver is rated 1,600 in-lbs and its circular saw spins at 4,700 RPM. BLACK+DECKER does not publish comparable figures for this kit.
Which lasts longer?
The RYOBI is likely to last longer under heavy use because of its higher-rated motors and larger battery platform. The BLACK+DECKER is fine for light, occasional work but is not built for daily jobsite use.
Do both include batteries and a charger?
The RYOBI includes two 18V 1.5 Ah batteries. BLACK+DECKER lists a 20V MAX lithium-ion battery and a case but does not state the count, so check the box contents before buying.
Can I add more tools later?
Yes on both, but RYOBI ONE+ has a much wider range of bare tools that use the same 18V batteries. BLACK+DECKER 20V MAX also has a line of bare tools, though a smaller one.

More comparisons

  • Ryobi 18V ONE+ Cordless 6-Tool Combo Kit (PCL1600K2) vs RYOBI P884 18V ONE+ 6-Tool Combo Kit
  • Ryobi 18V ONE+ Cordless 6-Tool Combo Kit (PCL1600K2) vs BLACK+DECKER 20V MAX MATRIX 6-Tool

Buying guides that pick them

  • Best Ryobi 18V ONE+ cordless tool kits
  • Best 6-piece cordless power tool combo kits
  • Best cordless power tool combo kits with drill/driver and circular saw