Safavieh Chelsea Mabelle Floral Wool Rug vs Rugs USA Melrose Checked Wool Area Rug

Buy the Safavieh Chelsea if you want a traditional floral look in a wool rug with a thicker pile. Buy the Rugs USA Melrose if you want a graphic checked pattern and a larger pool of owner feedback. Both are hand-tufted wool in a similar size, so the choice comes down to pattern and feel. The Chelsea has the higher average rating but from far fewer reviews, while the Melrose has a huge review base and a slightly lower score.

• Choose the Safavieh Chelsea if you want a classic ivory-and-green floral design and a plush 0.4-inch wool pile.
• Choose the Rugs USA Melrose if you prefer a clean checked pattern and want to lean on hundreds of owner reviews.