Salomon XA PRO 3D Gore-Tex Trail Shoes vs Salomon Speedcross 6

The Speedcross 6 is the better pick for most trail runners: it is about 3.5 oz lighter, has deeper aggressive lugs for soft and muddy ground, and a huge owner base rating it 4.6. The XA PRO 3D GTX wins when weather and rocky terrain matter, thanks to its GORE-TEX membrane and the 3D chassis that stabilizes the foot on uneven ground. Build on both is solid Salomon quality, but the XA PRO's waterproof upper runs warmer and heavier, and its 12 mm drop suits heel strikers more than the Speedcross's 10 mm.

• Choose the XA PRO 3D GTX if you run or hike in wet, cold or rocky conditions and want a waterproof shoe with extra stability underfoot.
• Choose the Speedcross 6 if you want a lighter, faster trail shoe with aggressive grip for mud, loose dirt and soft ground.