Which is better for backpacking with a heavy load?

The Salomon Quest 4 GTX. Its 4D chassis and EnergyCell midsole are built for stability under weight, and the toecap and mudguard add protection. The Zodiac Plus GTX is stiffer but has less cushioning for long descents.

Which grips better on rock?

The Scarpa Zodiac Plus GTX. Its Vibram Drumlin/Mont sole is widely praised for grip on rock and steep ascents. The Salomon contaGRIP outsole is solid all-terrain rubber but less specialized.

Is the Scarpa worth the extra money?

If you scramble or climb moderate technical terrain, yes. It is about 110 g lighter per boot and stiffer torsionally. For plain hiking with a heavy pack, the Quest 4 GTX does the job for less.

Which fits wider feet?

The Salomon Quest 4 GTX, which uses a regular width. The Scarpa Zodiac Plus GTX runs small and narrow, though it has a roomy toe box and secure heel hold.

The Salomon's leather and textile upper and rubber rand construction are durable, but the Scarpa's suede upper is also tough. Scarpa owners report the sole wears relatively quickly and waterproofing can eventually leak.

Which is better for winter hiking?

The Salomon Quest 4 GTX lists a touch of insulation and a winter season rating, so it suits cold-weather hiking better. The Scarpa is a three-season mountain hiker with GORE-TEX Performance Comfort.

Salomon Quest 4 GTX vs Scarpa Zodiac Plus GTX

The Scarpa Zodiac Plus GTX is the better boot for technical terrain, scrambling and buyers who want a light, precise fit. The Salomon Quest 4 GTX is the better pick for heavy packs, long expeditions and anyone who wants a plush, supportive ride with a protective toe cap. On price, the Quest 4 GTX has traded between $95.55 and $199.00 since November 4, while the Zodiac Plus GTX has sat at $209.40 since November 3. The Scarpa costs more and has a much smaller review base, but its 4.6 rating from 31 ratings beats Salomon's 3.6 from 627.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.