Which is better for walking all day?

The Dr. Martens Mattison. It has a cushioning support type and a platform rubber sole, while the Presley has a thin synthetic insole and a 2.375-inch heel.

Which has more sizes?

The Mattison, which comes in a full women's size run. The Presley listing shows only sizes 6½, 7 and 9.

Which is better for a dressy summer outfit?

The Presley. Its minimalist leather upper and 2.375-inch heel suit dresses and occasions; the Mattison's platform reads more casual.

Which holds up better over time?

The Mattison's rubber platform sole and ankle strap are built for heavier wear. The Presley is a lighter sandal, so expect more wear on the insole and heel.

Sam Edelman Presley Sandal vs Dr. Martens Mattison Strap Sandals

Q: Which is cheaper?

The Presley, at $58.50 to $65.00 since October 28, 2026. No current price was given for the Mattison, so compare its live price.

Buy the Sam Edelman Presley if you want a lighter, dressier sandal with a 2.375-inch heel and a lower price. Buy the Dr. Martens Mattison if you want a cushioned platform sandal built for all-day walking. The Presley has ranged from $58.50 to $65.00 since October 28, 2026; no current price was given for the Mattison, so check its live price before deciding.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.