Samantha Scoop Neck Charmeuse Blouse vs Beyond Travel Cold Shoulder Three Quarter Sleeve Top
Both are Boston Proper tops, but they solve different problems. The Samantha is a silky, sleeveless charmeuse blouse for dressier layering; the Beyond Travel is a stretchy, wrinkle-resistant knit with cold-shoulder cutouts for travel and casual days. The Beyond Travel has the stronger track record (4.3 from 149 ratings vs 4.9 from 39) and is machine washable, while the Samantha needs hand washing. Check current prices at each store before deciding, since neither is listed here.
Ask our shopping agent
Samantha Scoop Neck Charmeuse Blouse
4.9Choose the Samantha Scoop Neck Charmeuse Blouse if you want a fluid, luminous sleeveless layer for under a blazer or with tailored pants, and you don't mind hand washing.
- Silky charmeuse drapes fluidly and layers well under a blazer
- Scoop neckline and bust darts give a clean, feminine line
- Side vents add ease at the hem
- Highest rating in the pair at 4.9
- Hand wash only
- Sleeveless, so it needs a layer in cool weather
- Only 39 ratings, a small sample
- Polyester charmeuse can feel warm
What separates them
| Samantha Scoop Neck Charmeuse Blouse | Beyond Travel Cold Shoulder Three Quarter Sleeve Top | |
|---|---|---|
| Fabric | 96% polyester, 4% spandex charmeuse with a silky sheen | 95% nylon, 5% spandex double knit with four-way stretch |
| Sleeves | Sleeveless | Three-quarter sleeves with cold-shoulder cutouts |
| Care | Hand wash | Machine wash |
| Wrinkle resistance | Not specified | Wrinkle-resistant |
| Length (size small) | 25 inches | 27 inches |
| Neckline | Scoop | Square with cold-shoulder cutouts |
| Lining | Not lined | Partially lined |
| Ratings |
Price history
- Samantha Scoop Neck Charmeuse Blouse: lowest $39.00 on Nov 1 at Boston Proper.
- Beyond Travel Cold Shoulder Three Quarter Sleeve Top: lowest $24.98 on Nov 1 at Boston Proper.
Prices at every store
Samantha Scoop Neck Charmeuse Blouse
- Boston ProperCheck price at Boston Proper
- Boston ProperCheck price at Boston Proper
Beyond Travel Cold Shoulder Three Quarter Sleeve Top
- Boston ProperCheck price at Boston Proper
- Boston ProperCheck price at Boston Proper
Specs compared
| Spec | Samantha Scoop Neck Charmeuse Blouse | Beyond Travel Cold Shoulder Three Quarter Sleeve Top |
|---|---|---|
| Material composition | 96% polyester, 4% spandex | 95% nylon/5% spandex |
| Length | 25" length, based on size small | 27 inches, based on size small |
| Available sizes | XXS(0), XS(2-4), S(6-8), M(10-12), L(14-16), XL… | XXS(0), XS(2-4), S(6-8), M(10-12), L(14-16), XL… |
| Neckline | Scoop neckline | Square neckline with cold-shoulder cutouts |
| Closure style | Easy, pullover style | Easy, pullover style |
| Care instructions | Hand Wash | Machine wash |
| Sleeve style | Sleeveless | — |
| Design details | Side vents | — |
| Country of origin | Imported | — |
What reviewers say
Samantha Scoop Neck Charmeuse Blouse
Rated 4.9 out of 5 from 39 ratings on Boston Proper's page, a small but very positive sample. Owners tend to praise the fabric feel and the flattering neckline.
- Silky, fluid drape
- Flattering scoop neckline
- Dresses up easily for work or evening
- Hand wash care is a hassle
- Fabric can feel warm
Beyond Travel Cold Shoulder Three Quarter Sleeve Top
Rated 4.3 out of 5 across 149 ratings, the top draws praise for its stretch and travel-friendly fabric. Complaints center on the cold-shoulder cut and fit through the arms.
- Soft, stretchy double-knit fabric
- Holds up well with little wrinkling
- Flattering shaped fit
Questions and answers
- Which is better for travel?
- The Beyond Travel. It is wrinkle-resistant, machine washable, and has four-way stretch, all of which matter on the road. The Samantha is hand wash only and its charmeuse shows creases more readily.
- Which works for a dressy occasion?
- The Samantha. Its charmeuse sheen and scoop neckline read dressier, especially under a blazer or with tailored pants. The Beyond Travel is labeled for daytime.
- Which lasts longer?
- The Beyond Travel is easier to keep looking new because it is machine washable and wrinkle-resistant. Hand washing the Samantha gently will protect its sheen, but charmeuse is more delicate than the double knit.
- Do they fit the same?
- No. The Samantha is a straight pullover blouse with side vents; the Beyond Travel is a shaped fit that skims the body. Both run XXS to XL, but check the size chart for each.
- Is the Samantha worth it despite hand washing?
- If you want a silky sleeveless layer, yes. If low-maintenance care matters more, the Beyond Travel is the practical pick.
