Samsung RS27T5200SR Side-by-Side Refrigerator vs Frigidaire Gallery 25.6-cu ft Standard-Depth 36-in Wide Side-by-Side Refrigerator with Ice Maker, Water and Ice Dispenser (Fingerprint Resistant Stainless Steel)

Both are 36-inch standard-depth side-by-sides with in-door ice and water. The Samsung RS27T5200SR gives you more usable capacity, about 1.8 cu. ft. more, and a fingerprint-resistant black stainless finish; the Frigidaire Gallery GRSS2652AF is the safer pick if you want a plain, dependable dispenser and Energy Star efficiency. Owners of the Samsung praise the roomy, well-laid-out interior and quiet cooling but repeatedly flag the ice maker as slow and the dispenser as poorly designed. The Frigidaire is the more conservative choice: fewer smart extras, simpler controls, and no standout complaints.

• Choose the Samsung RS27T5200SR if you want the most interior room in a 36-inch side-by-side and like the recessed-handle, smudge-resistant look.
• Choose the Frigidaire Gallery if you want a straightforward Energy Star side-by-side and would rather not gamble on a fussy ice maker.