- Which is better for trail running?
- The Scarpa Spin Ultra. Its Vibram Megagrip outsole and TPU toe cap are built for rocks, roots and wet dirt, which the Puma lacks.
- Which is better for road running?
- The Puma Magnify Nitro 2. Its soft Nitro foam and engineered mesh upper suit pavement and daily miles better than a firm trail shoe.
- Which lasts longer?
- The Scarpa's Vibram rubber and reinforced toe usually hold up better on rough ground. The Puma's softer foam and mesh wear faster on abrasive surfaces, but last well on roads.
- Is one worth the extra?
- They cost about the same at their recent lows, $44.90 for the Scarpa and $47.95 for the Puma. Pick by terrain, not price.
- Can I use the Puma on light trails?
- Only on smooth, dry paths. It has no aggressive lugs or toe cap, so it slips on wet roots and loose gravel.
- Do both fit neutral runners?
- Yes. The Puma is listed for neutral pronation, and the Scarpa is a neutral trail platform. Neither offers stability posting.