Which is better for rocky, wet trails?

The Scarpa Vento GTX. Its Vibram XS Trek outsole and PU toe rand are built for slippery rock and toe strikes. The Keen Targhee III Mid has a plain rubber outsole and no toe rand.

Which is better for hot-weather day hikes?

The Keen Targhee III Mid. It is listed as breathable with a mesh upper and arch support. The Scarpa lists waterproofing but no breathability.

Is the Keen worth the price?

At $62.95 at eBay as of November 7, 2026, it is a low-cost waterproof hiker with a 4.3 out of 5 score from 1,200 ratings. That is strong value if you do not need a Vibram sole.

Which has more arch support?

The Keen Targhee III Mid lists built-in arch support. The Scarpa Vento GTX lists general support but no arch feature.

Neither maker publishes a lifespan figure. The Scarpa's Vibram outsole and PU toe rand are the more abrasion-resistant build on paper; the Keen's 1,200 ratings give you more real-world feedback.

Do both come in women's sizes?

Yes. Both are women's boots with lace-up closure and waterproof construction. The Keen is listed in medium width only.

Scarpa Vento GTX Women's Boot vs Keen Targhee III Mid Waterproof Boots

Buy the Keen Targhee III Mid if you want a proven, widely reviewed waterproof hiker at a low price; it is $62.95 at eBay as of November 7, 2026, and 5 stores carry it new. Buy the Scarpa Vento GTX if you want a stiffer, more protective boot with a Vibram outsole and a PU toe rand for rough, rocky trails. The Scarpa is the more technical boot; the Keen is the easier value.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.