Scenario High Rise Straight Leg Jeans vs Gloria Vanderbilt Amanda High Rise Jeans

Both are high-rise straight-leg jeans with stretch, so the choice comes down to fit range and hem style. The Gloria Vanderbilt Amanda is the safer pick: it has decades of sales behind it, hundreds of ratings, and comes in petite lengths and a wide waist range, which suits shorter shoppers and anyone who wants a tapered leg. The Scenario pair adds a let-down hem for a more styled look and comes in plus sizes, but it has far fewer ratings and only one listed size and color. Buy the Amanda for everyday wear and reliable sizing; buy the Scenario for the raw-hem detail and plus sizing.

• Choose the Scenario if you want a let-down hem detail, need plus sizing, or prefer a straighter leg over a tapered one.
• Choose the Gloria Vanderbilt Amanda if you are petite, want a tapered leg with slimming interior pockets, or want the confidence of a long-running bestseller with many more owner reviews.