Scepter 5 Gallon Military Style Water Container vs Reliance Aqua-Tainer 7 Gallon

Buy the Scepter if you want a tough, compact 5-gallon jug that survives being thrown in a truck bed and carried by one hand. Buy the Reliance Aqua-Tainer if you want more water per trip, a spigot you can pour from without lifting the container, and a vented cap that fills and empties faster. The Scepter has the sturdier molded-in handle and a higher owner rating from a smaller sample; the Aqua-Tainer has a much larger review base and is the more versatile camp kitchen container, though owners say its plastic is thinner and the caps need firm tightening.

• Choose the Scepter if you need a rugged, BPA-free 5-gallon jug with a molded-in handle for hauling water on hikes, in a truck, or during an emergency.
• Choose the Reliance Aqua-Tainer if you want 7 gallons, a hideaway spigot for dispensing, and a vented cap for faster flow at camp.