Scooch Wingback vs CX-5 Magnetic Rotatable Phone Holder

Buy the Scooch Wingback if you want one flat accessory that grips, kickstands and mounts in an air vent. Buy the aluminum magnetic holder if you want a desk stand and selfie stick and already use a MagSafe-style magnetic case. The Wingback is the more versatile pocket accessory, but owners report the adhesive weakens and the snap hinge wears out after a few years. The magnetic holder is sturdier in metal and rotates freely, but it does nothing for a phone in the hand and needs magnets to hold.

• Choose the Scooch Wingback if you want a slim stick-on grip that also props the phone and slots into a car air vent.
• Choose the CX-5 magnetic holder if you want a folding aluminum stand for a desk or selfies and your phone or case is magnetic.