StoreDeal.ai store
Shop
  • Deals
  • Deal checker
  • Black Friday
  • Buying guides
  • Brands
  • Stores
Travel
  • Flight deals
  • Hotel deals
Company
  • Research
  • Press
  • Use in AI assistants
  • Contact
  • deal.ai apps
Black Friday 2026
  • Walmart
  • Best Buy
  • Target
  • TVs
  • Laptops
  • Headphones
  • Apple
  • Gaming
  • Vacuums
  • Kitchen
  • Toys
  • Smartwatches
  • Tablets
  • Furniture
  • Mattresses
© Deal.ai Inc.·2222 Ponce de Leon Blvd, Miami, FL 33134·support@deal.ai
TermsPrivacy
Deal.ai › Compare

Sephora Favorites Beauty Set vs SHANY All In One Makeup Set

Buy the Sephora Favorites set if you want a curated mix of well-known brands and a fragrance in travel sizes. Buy the SHANY All In One Makeup Set if you want a large palette of pressed powders for stage, dance or practice. The Sephora set has three full sizes, two minis and four deluxe items, but only 3.7 out of 5 from 3 reviews at Kohl's, and one reviewer reported a highlighter arriving broken. SHANY rates 4.4 out of 5 from 118 ratings and offers full, buildable coverage, but it is pressed powders only and listed for medium skin.

  • Choose the Sephora Favorites if you want recognizable brands like Bobbi Brown, Glow Recipe, Milk Makeup and Ilia in one gift set, plus a scented eau de parfum.
  • Choose the SHANY All In One Makeup Set if you need many eyeshadow, lip and face colors in one reusable case for performances or practice.

Prices

  • Sephora Favorites Beauty Set: $49.86 at eBay (checked today)
  • SHANY All In One Makeup Set: $11.99 at Zaffy (last seen Nov 20)
  • Difference: the SHANY All In One Makeup Set is $37.87 cheaper than the Sephora Favorites Beauty Set at the latest prices (Nov 20 and Nov 22)
Sephora
Sephora Favorites

Sephora Favorites Beauty Set

Sephora Favorites

3.7(3 ratings)
$49.86at eBayChecked 4 h ago
See all prices and details
Visit eBay

Store links may earn us a commission.

Pros
  • Includes full sizes from Bobbi Brown, Glow Recipe, Milk Makeup and Ilia
  • Travel sizes suit trying products before buying full sizes
  • Covers face, body and hair with a scented eau de parfum
  • Talc-free and aluminum-free
  • Full sizes of Brow Freeze, ILIA mascara and KVD Tattoo Liner
Cons
  • Only 3.7 out of 5 from 3 reviews at Kohl's
  • One reviewer reported a highlighter arriving broken
  • No full-coverage base or broad shade range
SHANY Cosmetics
SHANY All In One Makeup Set

SHANY All In One Makeup Set

4.4(118 ratings)
$11.99at ZaffyChecked Nov 20
See all prices and details
Visit Zaffy
Pros
  • 4.4 out of 5 from 118 ratings
  • Full, buildable coverage with matte and shimmer finishes
  • Reusable case holds eyeshadows, lip colors, liners and applicators
  • Water-resistant and includes a color corrector
Cons
  • Pressed powders only, no sprays, balms or fragrance
  • 3 lb kit is heavy to carry
  • Listed for medium skin and normal skin type, so shade match is narrow
  • No named prestige brands inside

What separates them

Sephora Favorites Beauty SetSHANY All In One Makeup Set
What is insideThree full sizes, two minis and four deluxe items from named brandsPressed powder eyeshadows, face powders, foundations, lipsticks, lipgloss and applicators in one kit
FormatsSpray, balm, powder, cream and toner across face, body and hairPressed powders only, matte and shimmer
FragranceScented with bergamot and hinoki, eau de parfum strengthNo fragrance listed
Size and portabilityTravel size, easy to pack3 lb kit in a reusable case
CoverageNot statedFull, buildable coverage
Skin tone rangeShades chosen by Sephora, not listed per toneListed for medium skin, normal skin type
Ratings3.7 out of 5 from 3 reviews at Kohl's4.4 out of 5 from 118 ratings
Full sizesFull sizes of Anastasia Beverly Hills Brow Freeze, ILIA Limitless Lash Mascara and KVD Tattoo LinerNo single full-size product; the kit is one large palette
Skin care ingredientsContains vegan collagen, bio-retinol, BHA and PHA, and is talc-free and aluminum-freeNo skin care actives listed
Color correctorNot listedIncludes a color corrector

Price history

$85.00$11.99
Oct 31Nov 22
  • Sephora Favorites Beauty Set: lowest $49.86 on Nov 22 at eBay.
  • SHANY All In One Makeup Set: lowest $11.99 on Nov 20 at Zaffy.

Prices at every store

Sephora Favorites Beauty Set

  • eBayNew

    In stock

    $49.86Free shippingChecked 4 h ago
    Visit eBay
  • Les Appartements de JujuNew

    In stock

    $59.00Checked Nov 10
    Visit Les Appartements de Juju
  • WhatnotNew

    In stock

    $55.00+ $8.35 shippingChecked Nov 9
    Visit Whatnot
  • Uber EatsNew

    Availability unknown

    $85.00Checked Nov 14
    Visit Uber Eats

Store links may earn us a commission.

All 9 stores and price history →

SHANY All In One Makeup Set

  • WalmartNew

    In stock

    $27.34+ $6.99 shippingChecked Nov 20
    Visit Walmart
  • ZaffyNew

    Availability unknownSold by Aromatica s.r.l.Ships from Italy · duties may apply

    $11.99Checked Nov 20
    Visit Zaffy
  • DepopNew

    Availability unknown

    $20.00Checked Nov 20
    Visit Depop
  • PoshmarkNew

    Availability unknown

    $22.00Checked Nov 20
    Visit Poshmark

Also available at

  • WalmartCheck price at Walmart
All 11 stores and price history →

Specs compared

SpecSephora Favorites Beauty SetSHANY All In One Makeup Set
SizeTravel Size3.0000
Free OfTalc-Free, Aluminum-FreeCruelty-free, Non Toxic
UnscentedNoYes
OccasionAny occasionEveryday
Is A PaletteNo—
Is A SetGift set—
Suitable GenderWomen—
DepartmentWomen—
FormSpray, Balm Powder, Cream, Toner—
ScentedYes—
Scent NotesBergamot & Hinoki—
TypeMakeup Set, Gift Set—
Show all 40 specsShow fewer specs
SpecSephora Favorites Beauty SetSHANY All In One Makeup Set
Application TypeDry Shampoo, Setting Spray—
Body PartFace, Body, Hair—
Fragrance StrengthEau de Parfum—
ContainsVegan Collagen, BHA, Bio-Retinol, PHA—
Ingredients HighlightsVegan Collagen, Bio-Retinol—
Typical UsersPeople who love to try before they buy—
Sustainability CertificationVegan—
Packaging TypeSet—
Packaging HighlightsSet—

What reviewers say

Sephora Favorites Beauty Set

Reviewers call the set good value, with several full-size products plus minis that make it easy to try new items. One reviewer reported a highlighter arriving broken.

What people mention
  • ValuePraisedReviewers say the mix of full sizes and minis is good value for the price.
  • Trying firstPraisedBuyers like sampling minis before committing to full sizes.
  • PackagingCriticisedOne reviewer received a highlighter broken on arrival.
  • Body lotionPraisedThe Rare Beauty lotion is called travel-friendly, moisturizing and pleasant-smelling.

SHANY All In One Makeup Set

  • 4.4 / 5118 ratings

Buyers rate the set 4.4 out of 5 across 118 ratings. Most see it as good value for beginners and performers who want many colors in one case. Complaints center on powder texture and uneven pigmentation.

What people mention
  • ValuePraisedBuyers say the kit delivers a lot of product for the money.
  • Shade rangePraisedOwners like the mix of warm and cool tones for stage and everyday looks.
  • PigmentationMixedSome shades apply richly while others need several layers to show up.

Questions and answers

Which is better for a beginner?
SHANY, because it packs eyeshadows, lip colors, liners and applicators in one case. The Sephora set is better for trying named brands in travel sizes.
Which lasts longer?
SHANY's pressed powders carry full, buildable coverage and a 3 lb kit that lasts through many uses. The Sephora set is travel size, so the minis run out sooner.
Which is better for stage or dance?
SHANY. It is built for dancers and theater performers, with matte and shimmer pressed powders and full coverage. The Sephora set is a gift set for everyday looks.
Does the Sephora set include fragrance?
Yes. It is scented with bergamot and hinoki at eau de parfum strength. SHANY lists no fragrance.
Is the Sephora set worth stepping up to?
It is if you want full sizes from Bobbi Brown, Glow Recipe, Milk Makeup and Ilia plus a scented eau de parfum. SHANY gives more colors but no prestige brands.
What full sizes are in the Sephora set?
Anastasia Beverly Hills Brow Freeze, ILIA Limitless Lash Mascara and KVD Beauty Tattoo Liner come full size. The rest are minis or deluxe sizes.
Does the Sephora set have skin care ingredients?
Yes. It lists vegan collagen, bio-retinol, BHA and PHA, and it is talc-free and aluminum-free. SHANY lists no skin care actives.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.

Enter to send, Shift+Enter for a new line

More comparisons

  • Sephora Favorites vs Charlotte Tilbury Pillow Talk Icons On the Go Kit
  • Makeup Sets for Women Full Kit vs Sephora Favorites
  • Makeup Made Simple Kit (3PC) vs Sephora Favorites
  • Makeup Sets for Women Full Kit vs SHANY All In One Makeup Set
Weight (oz)
2.82
—
ContentAntioxidants—
No. of Pieces (pcs)8—
Color category—Black
Makeup form—Pressed Powders
Brand—SHANY Cosmetics
Product line—Shany
Makeup finish—Matte, Shimmer, Gloss
Color—Black
Skin tone—Medium
Product net content uom—Each
Age group—Adult, Teen
Skin type—Normal
Items included—Eyeshadows, Makeup Applicators, Face Powders, F…
Assembled product weight—3 lb
Makeup coverage—Full
Product net content parent—1 Each
Retail packaging—Kit
Product multifunction descriptor—All In One Makeup Kit
  • Powder textureCriticisedSeveral reviewers find the pressed powders chalky and prone to fallout.