Sephora Favorites Beauty Set vs SHANY All In One Makeup Set
Buy the Sephora Favorites set if you want a curated mix of well-known brands and a fragrance in travel sizes. Buy the SHANY All In One Makeup Set if you want a large palette of pressed powders for stage, dance or practice. The Sephora set has three full sizes, two minis and four deluxe items, but only 3.7 out of 5 from 3 reviews at Kohl's, and one reviewer reported a highlighter arriving broken. SHANY rates 4.4 out of 5 from 118 ratings and offers full, buildable coverage, but it is pressed powders only and listed for medium skin.
- Choose the Sephora Favorites if you want recognizable brands like Bobbi Brown, Glow Recipe, Milk Makeup and Ilia in one gift set, plus a scented eau de parfum.
- Choose the SHANY All In One Makeup Set if you need many eyeshadow, lip and face colors in one reusable case for performances or practice.
Prices
- Sephora Favorites Beauty Set: $49.86 at eBay (checked today)
- SHANY All In One Makeup Set: $11.99 at Zaffy (last seen Nov 20)
- Difference: the SHANY All In One Makeup Set is $37.87 cheaper than the Sephora Favorites Beauty Set at the latest prices (Nov 20 and Nov 22)

