Serta 12-in Firm Queen Hybrid Mattress vs Ashley Firm Queen Mattress

The Serta is the better mattress of the two. It is a true hybrid: memory foam over a coil base, with a cooling cover and 12 inches of firm support. The Ashley is an all-foam bed with a quilted knit cover that ships in a box. Reviewers of firm hybrids like the Serta praise the balance of firm support and pressure relief; owners of boxed all-foam beds like the Ashley often note they sleep warm and soften faster. Buy the Serta for long-term daily use. Buy the Ashley only if you want a simple, light all-foam queen that is easy to move and set up.

• Choose the Serta if you want a firm hybrid with memory foam and coil support for everyday sleeping and a cooler feel.
• Choose the Ashley if you want a basic all-foam firm queen that ships compressed in a box and is easy to carry upstairs or into a small room.