Which dresser holds more?

The West Elm wins on drawer depth: 14.2 inches versus 6.5 inches on the Shaker. Both have six drawers, so the West Elm stores noticeably more per drawer.

Which is better for a small bedroom?

The West Elm is 5 inches shorter at 32 inches, so it fits under lower windows and keeps the room feeling open. The Shaker is taller at 37.125 inches and gives more top surface height.

Is the Shaker worth the extra cost?

At its recent low of $549.00 on November 2, 2026, the Shaker is solid alder with 27 finish combinations. The West Elm price was not given, so check both live prices before deciding whether the premium is justified.

Which has better drawer construction?

The West Elm uses both English and French dovetail joinery; the Shaker uses English dovetail only. Both use metal glides, so the West Elm has a slight edge on joinery.

Which is safer for indoor air quality?

The West Elm carries GREENGUARD Gold certification, screened for over 10,000 chemicals and VOCs. The Shaker is GREENGUARD certified with a low-VOC finish, which is a step below Gold.

How much assembly does each need?

The Shaker requires full assembly. West Elm does not state assembly requirements in the specs given, so confirm with the store before ordering.

Shaker 6-Drawer Dresser vs West Elm Mid-Century 6-Drawer Dresser

Buy the Shaker 6-Drawer Dresser if you want solid alder wood, a taller 37-inch profile, and a choice of 14 stains and 13 paints. Buy the West Elm Mid-Century 6-Drawer Dresser if you want a lower 32-inch cabinet with deeper 14.2-inch drawers and GREENGUARD Gold certification. The Shaker's lowest recent price was $549.00 on November 2, 2026, against a high of $1,049.99 on October 30, 2026. No current price was given for the West Elm, so compare live store prices before deciding.

Ask our shopping agent