SHANY Bundle Makeup Set vs Aolikoko Makeup Kit for Women Full Kit
Buy the Aolikoko kit if you want the most pieces for the least money: $19.80 at Walmart as of the listed price, against $49.98 at Target for the SHANY bundle. Buy the SHANY set if you want a single branded box with a shimmer highlighter and contour focus, and you value the deeper markdown from a $199.98 list price. The Aolikoko kit is the better value on paper, but its 3.6 rating from 215 ratings and the SHANY's 3.3 from 126 both point to mixed results.
Ask our shopping agent
SHANY Bundle Makeup Set
3.3Choose the SHANY bundle if you want a gift-ready black box set with shimmer highlighter and contour shades for teens and pre-teens.
- Gift-ready black box aimed at teens and pre-teens
- Shimmer highlighter and contour focus suits going-out looks
- Cruelty-free and unscented
- Deep markdown from a $199.98 list price
- No foundation, concealer or brush listed in the set
- Only 3.3 out of 5 from 126 ratings
- Shimmer finish limits everyday wear
- Color may vary, so the shades you get are not fixed
What separates them
| SHANY Bundle Makeup Set | Aolikoko Makeup Kit for Women Full Kit | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $49.98 at Target as of the listed date | $19.80 at Walmart as of the listed date |
| Stated discount | 75% off a $199.98 regular price | 67% off a $59.99 regular price |
| Piece count | Sold as one set; count not itemized | 31 pieces, itemized on the listing |
| Base products | No foundation or concealer listed | Two liquid foundations and a concealer stick included |
| Finish | Shimmer, built around highlighter and contour | Matte, natural, velvet and high sheen across the kit |
| Skin claims | Cruelty-free and unscented only | Hypoallergenic, non-comedogenic, non-irritating, SPF 15 |
| Rating | 3.3 out of 5 from 126 ratings |
Price history
- SHANY Bundle Makeup Set: lowest $49.98 on Oct 28 at Target; $49.98 on Oct 30.
- Aolikoko Makeup Kit for Women Full Kit: lowest $19.80 on Oct 28.
Prices at every store
Specs compared
| Spec | SHANY Bundle Makeup Set | Aolikoko Makeup Kit for Women Full Kit |
|---|---|---|
| Container Type | Box (SHANY Black Box) | Packet |
| Color | Color May vary | — |
| Coverage Level | Full | — |
| Primary Effect | Highlighter, Contour | — |
| Primary Finish | Shimmer | — |
| Form Type | Palette, Lipstick | — |
| Best For Skin Type | All | — |
| Body Part Use | Lips, Eyes | — |
| Application Method | Sponge, Brush | — |
| Unscented | Yes | — |
What reviewers say
SHANY Bundle Makeup Set
Ratings sit at 3.3 out of 5 across 126 reviews, which suggests a mixed reception: buyers like the volume and gift appeal, but quality and shade consistency draw complaints.
- Good value as a gift set
- Large amount of product for the price
- Attractive box presentation
- Inconsistent quality across items
- Shades and colors vary from what is pictured
- Shimmer and pigment payoff disappoint some buyers
Aolikoko Makeup Kit for Women Full Kit
With 3.6 out of 5 from 215 ratings, reception is mixed. Buyers tend to like the size of the set and the eyeshadow shades for the money, while complaints center on foundation shade match and the quality of the tools.
- Good value for the number of pieces
Questions and answers
- Which kit is better for a beginner?
- The Aolikoko kit covers more steps out of the box: foundation, concealer, blush, eyeshadow and lipstick. The SHANY set leans on highlighter and contour, which takes more practice.
- Which has more makeup for the money?
- Aolikoko. It lists 31 pieces for $19.80 at Walmart, against $49.98 at Target for the SHANY bundle, whose piece count is not itemized.
- Is the SHANY set worth the extra $30?
- Only if you want the black gift box and the shimmer highlighter and contour shades. On price per piece and rating, the Aolikoko kit wins.
- Which is better for medium skin tones?
- Aolikoko lists its shade set for medium skin tone. SHANY says only that color may vary, so you cannot pick a match.
- Do either include foundation?
- Aolikoko includes two nude liquid foundations and a concealer stick. The SHANY bundle lists no foundation or concealer.
- Which is better for a teen gift?
- The SHANY bundle is packaged in a signature black box and lists teens and pre-teens as its age range. The Aolikoko kit arrives in a packet.