Shop
  • Deals
  • Deal checker
  • Black Friday
  • Buying guides
  • Brands
  • Stores
Travel
  • Flight deals
  • Hotel deals
Company
  • Research
  • Press
  • deal.ai apps
Black Friday 2026
  • Walmart
  • Best Buy
  • Target
  • TVs
  • Laptops
  • Headphones
  • Apple
  • Gaming
  • Vacuums
  • Kitchen
  • Toys
  • Smartwatches
  • Tablets
  • Furniture
  • Mattresses
© Deal.ai Inc.
TermsPrivacy
Deal.ai › Compare

Tandy Sienna Flat Veg-Tan Side vs Catalina Veg-Tan Single Shoulder

Buy the Sienna Flat Side if you need volume, long belt or strap blanks, and leather you can tool, carve and mold. Buy the Catalina Single Shoulder if you want a smaller, drum-dyed piece with a glossy face for bags, wallets and linings. The Sienna is a full side with 17 to 22 sq. ft. and a 3 to 4 oz. even weight; the Catalina is a shoulder with 5 to 9 sq. ft. and a 2 to 4 oz. range, so it varies more across the hide. The Sienna is the better tooling leather; the Catalina is the better finished-look leather, though its gloss and no-stretch temper limit molding.

  • Choose the Sienna Flat Veg-Tan Side if you want a large side for belts, straps, holsters, sheaths or carving projects and need consistent 3 to 4 oz. thickness.
  • Choose the Catalina Veg-Tan Single Shoulder if you want a smaller, pre-dyed hide with a glossy top-grain face for handbags, wallets and linings.

Prices

  • Tandy Sienna Flat Veg-Tan Side: $129.99 at Tandy Leather (last seen Nov 9)
  • Catalina Veg-Tan Single Shoulder: $79.99 at Tandy Leather, Inc. (last seen Nov 9)
  • Difference: the Catalina Veg-Tan Single Shoulder is $50.00 cheaper than the Tandy Sienna Flat Veg-Tan Side at the latest prices (Nov 9)
S
Sienna Flat Veg-Tan Side

Tandy Sienna Flat Veg-Tan Side

Sienna Flat Veg-Tan Side

$129.99at Tandy LeatherChecked 20 h ago
See all prices and details
Visit Tandy Leather
Pros
  • Large side covers belts, straps and multiple projects
  • Even 3 to 4 oz. weight is predictable for tooling
  • Takes carving, stamping, embossing and molding well
  • Tannery-dyed black and brown give even color
  • 100% veg-tan with no harsh chemicals
Cons
  • Only 3 to 4 oz., too thick for thin linings
  • Matte face lacks the gloss some bag makers want
  • Large side is more leather than a small project needs
  • Limited stretch means less give for wrapped shapes
Catalina
Catalina Veg-Tan Single Shoulder

Catalina Veg-Tan Single Shoulder

$79.99at Tandy Leather, Inc.Checked 20 h ago
See all prices and details
Visit Tandy Leather, Inc.
Pros
  • High-gloss drum-dyed face needs little finishing
  • No stretch or pull-up keeps shapes clean
  • Top grain cowhide with a dressy look
  • Small shoulder suits wallets, linings and small bags
  • 2 oz. end is thin enough for linings
Cons
  • Small 5 to 9 sq. ft. shoulder limits large projects
  • Thickness varies from 2 to 4 oz. across the hide
  • Gloss and no-stretch temper make it poor for molding
  • Solvents and heat above 158°F damage it

What separates them

Tandy Sienna Flat Veg-Tan SideCatalina Veg-Tan Single Shoulder
Hide size17 to 22 sq. ft. per side5 to 9 sq. ft. per shoulder
Thickness3 to 4 oz. (1.2 to 1.6 mm), split to order2 to 4 oz. (0.8 to 1.6 mm), varies across the hide
SurfaceSmooth, matte, even color on dyed black and brownDrum-dyed top grain with a high-gloss finish
Tooling and moldingMade for carving, stamping, embossing and moldingNo stretch or pull-up; not sold for tooling
StretchVery limited stretch when dryNo stretch at all
Best projectsBelts, straps, tack, holsters, sheaths, briefcasesHandbags, wallets, linings, small goods
Care limitsStandard veg-tan careKeep below 158°F; no solvents, use leather wax or soap
Cut consistencyOne large side gives long continuous blanksSmaller shoulder limits long straps and belt blanks

Price history

  • Tandy Sienna Flat Veg-Tan Side: lowest $129.99 on Nov 9 at Tandy Leather.
  • Catalina Veg-Tan Single Shoulder: lowest $79.99 on Nov 9 at Tandy Leather.

Prices at every store

Tandy Sienna Flat Veg-Tan Side

  • Tandy LeatherNew

    In stock

    $129.99+ $19.99 shippingChecked 20 h ago
    Visit Tandy Leather
  • eBayPre-owned

    Availability unknown

    $45.00Free shippingChecked Nov 9
    Visit eBay

Also available at

  • Tandy Leather, Inc.Check price at Tandy Leather, Inc.

Store links may earn us a commission.

All 2 stores and price history →

Catalina Veg-Tan Single Shoulder

  • Tandy Leather, Inc.New

    In stockReturn policy

    $79.99Checked 20 h ago
    Visit Tandy Leather, Inc.

Also available at

  • Tandy LeatherCheck price at Tandy Leather
Prices and history →

Specs compared

SpecTandy Sienna Flat Veg-Tan SideCatalina Veg-Tan Single Shoulder
Weight/Thickness3 to 4 oz. (1.2 to 1.6 mm)2 to 4 oz. (0.8 to 1.6 mm)
Average Size17 to 22 sq. ft. (1.58 to 2.04 sq. meters)5 to 9 sq. ft. (0.46 to 0.84 sq. meters)
TannageVeg-TanVeg-Tan
MaterialVeg tanned leather, U.S. cowhide—
Upholstery TypeLeather—
TypeLeather—
SubtypeStrap Leather—
Craft TypeLeather work projects—
FormSide—
Quantity In Pack1—
Length85"-100" (approximate)—
Width30"-36" (approximate)—
Show all 15 specsShow fewer specs
SpecTandy Sienna Flat Veg-Tan SideCatalina Veg-Tan Single Shoulder
ThicknessSplit to a variety of thicknesses—
ApplicationTooling, Carving, Embossing, Molding, Stamping—
SustainabilityNo harsh chemicals—

What reviewers say

Tandy Sienna Flat Veg-Tan Side

Leathercrafters generally rate Tandy veg-tan sides as dependable, affordable stock for practice and small goods. They like the smooth, firm surface and consistent dye on the black and brown, but note that thickness and firmness vary across the hide.

What people mention
  • SurfacePraisedOwners say the smooth grain takes dye and burnishing evenly.
  • TemperMixedThe hide is firm and low-stretch, which some find stiff for folding projects.
  • ThicknessCriticisedBuyers report the 3 to 4 oz. weight varies noticeably across a single side.
  • DyePraisedThe tannery-dyed black and brown are described as even and consistent.

Catalina Veg-Tan Single Shoulder

Makers who use this shoulder describe a firm, glossy veg-tan that cuts cleanly and holds shape in wallets and linings. Some find the finish shows scratches and creases more than softer leathers, and a few note the firm temper limits molding.

What people mention
  • TemperMixedMakers like the firm, no-stretch body for structured pieces but say it resists molding and gathering.
  • FinishMixedThe high-gloss surface is praised for looking finished, yet it shows scratches and creases readily.
  • DyePraisedThe drum-dyed color is described as even across the hide and through the thickness.
  • WeightPraisedThe 2 to 4 oz. weight is called easy to skive and fold for wallets and linings.

Questions and answers

Which is better for tooling and carving?
The Sienna. It is sold for tooling, carving, embossing, molding and stamping, and its 3 to 4 oz. weight is even across the side. The Catalina has a glossy drum-dyed face and no stretch, so it is not the leather for carving.
Which is better for handbags and wallets?
The Catalina. Its high-gloss top-grain finish and no-stretch temper suit structured bags, wallets and linings. The Sienna works too, but its matte face and 3 to 4 oz. weight are heavier for small goods.
Which gives me more leather to work with?
The Sienna. A side runs 17 to 22 sq. ft.; a Catalina shoulder runs 5 to 9 sq. ft. The side also gives long continuous blanks for belts and straps that a shoulder cannot.
Which lasts longer?
Both are veg-tan cowhide and last for years with care. The Catalina needs more caution: keep it below 158°F and off solvents, and clean with leather wax or soap. The Sienna has no special care limits beyond normal veg-tan treatment.
Is the Catalina worth stepping up to over the Sienna?
Only if you want the glossy pre-dyed look and a smaller piece. If you need size, even thickness or tooling, the Sienna is the stronger choice.
Can I use the Catalina for belts?
Not well. A shoulder is 5 to 9 sq. ft. and its 2 to 4 oz. range is thin and uneven for belts. The Sienna side gives the length and 3 to 4 oz. weight belts need.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.

Enter to send, Shift+Enter for a new line

More comparisons

  • Economy Veg-Tan Side vs Sienna Flat Veg-Tan Side
  • Sienna Milled Veg-Tan Side vs Sienna Flat Veg-Tan Side
  • Economy Veg-Tan Side vs Catalina Veg-Tan Single Shoulder
  • Sienna Milled Veg-Tan Side vs Catalina Veg-Tan Single Shoulder

Buying guides that pick them

  • Best vegetable-tanned leather sides for leathercraft